Hi Tubz, as i mentioned before, i greatly appreciate the time you took to set up this forum. My criticism is that this thread/protocol does not seem to be the golden bullet, and rather emphasizing that people didnt read it correctly, i point out that a large test group did a clean run and no one really got cured.
Doesnt mean others didnt get cured before, although it is a minorty and several of them tried multiple things without a real proper log, so it is all but transparent for most of the readers here.
If the point is to learn and guide from some cured cases, then i would kindly suggest that this would be logged accordingly. If Gbold can cure Admiraal and Barbaar that would be amazing, really. But why not do that in a topic, where all their actions, discussions, questions, hairtests etc. are logged, so the rest can really learn from it?
Jaxx.. Honestly you keep saying same things over and over again. There was no large trial group . are you serious. it was only 5 people who just took electrolytes with amino acids for a week. I have no idea where you get this large trial thing. Tubzy was doing good on HCL plus electrolytes and set up the trial to see if this would help other people. It has nothing to do with this protocol. It had no minerals in it or hairtests, or multivitamins , nothing. I told Tubzy not to do it, and not to try to simplify things. And now you are talking about some trial. Tubzy posted this long list of people trying it. but it was only 5 people who did that thing for a week)) and it was purposely done in a private thread,since it was just experimental and had nothing to do with the approach I suggested.And then I told Tubzy to stop it since I looked at some of those people's hairtests and what they were doing was worthless.
I told you look at logs of Raincoast, Herrfish, goose 12, tubzy, Orion, March,Aztec, Scenes.,Ihate fin . Also you can look at suggestions of MattyB and his log,he is doing similar things also and has some very good points also on diet, and electrolytes balance. Those people who are trying to follow some of the things I suggested like RU ella , and ARL hairtest thing., and fasting.. And no they were not trying random things. and this is not a minority . It is a majority of this forum. These are all active forumers. Minority is the people who are doing random stuff. who I dont even know. Like admiral, Yura, Health . I never dealt with them. And they are a minority. Really get your story straight. I am wasting my time answering and clearing this up to you already 5 times. And you still return to your previous statements about some large trial.
You can look at logs of these people, instead you look at logs of Admiral. Who I have no clue what he is doing. He seems to just waste money on random stuff, and not listen to what I am saying. I never worked with him. and I am not going to take on case by case of everyone who comes here and is struggling.
As of now I took on one case of PSSD ( barbar). Read his messages he is already doing better.
I keep repeating this to you over and over again. And you choose to look at logs or questions of some random people who are not even part of the core of this forum. It is like you are looking and learning from failure? why? Why do you want to learn from people who are doing some random stuff. Who don't have a plan.
If the first post in this thread is not straight forward to you. Then I cant help you either. And please dont give me stuff about admiral.I never worked with him. I have no idea what he is doing. And I am not going to keep taking cases case by case. I already took people on and fixed them , I dont have to keep proving to you that it works.
If you are skeptical and dont believe you can be cured this way. Just dont do any of this. And dont be part of this forum. You can always go to Ray Peats forum or Ghost;s forum and be there. There is a protocol outlined on the first page of this thread. It says exactly what to do. from A to Z. If people chose to do some weird parts of the protocol. Setup weird trials that do some weird parts of the protocol. they will always do it and I have no control over it. Someone can read it and see only salt in it. some can read and see only magnesium and potassium in it. Etc. Some like Yura can only see lack of stomach acid, and may be it will work for him etc, but it is not a protocol that I outined. Some like LEgna want to salt load , good for them, they are trying , but they are also not doing any of this protocol. Health is just trying some random stuff, and has a very good log. But people who are doing better suggest him to get a a hairtest and get balanced.
You can always go on Raincoast log , or Herrfish log , or March log, Or Tubzy log , or Orion log and ask for advice how to proceed. Those people got it and think in the right direction. But you instead look at people who did nto get it. How can I explain to WUF to follow the program. HOw? He does not get what to do, I look at his og and he is just all over the place. I cant baby sit him. I tell him , dear WUF, get ARL program , and just be on it , buy supplements from ARL and DONT think. We have different people on this forum. Some know how to navigate thru all this info and some don't. You choose to look at people who don't know how to navigate thru this info. Sorry but it is a dead end.
My advice to you . Get a log here, contact Catherine. get a hairtest , program and take the supplements. And then in your log, you can ask questions and collab with other people who are already doing the same .like Raincoast, Tubzy, Herrfish, March. to mention a few. These are the majority and the most active member of this forum. If you keep reading this thread , it wont get you anywhere. Since this thread has no feedbacks and no one is following a proper protocol