Which acids are good for stomach? How to use acids like HCl?

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
I don't know what makes my stomach burn those days.... The problem started with the Peat high fruit diet, and I had to stop bananas in the evening, or else I would wake up with acid reflux.

FIXED by:
- Be brave enough to get up and drink cider vinegar, and then just enough water to cool the burn.

Ok, this means I lack acid?

I have never been able to go up more than 1 betaine Hcl at once, and even with one, I ended up with stomach burn, so I stopped it. The burn is NOT at the same place. With Hcl it is lower, really in the stomach.

As confirmed by sharing in the forum, by mattyb using ACV, and also being a slow 1 with low phosphorus, and advised by the lab to take hcl. Ok let's start again....

I had dermatographia as a child, fits in what mattyb said, never got hives, and was advised to take HCl after hair test.
BUT I seem to have problem with acids (my less liked taste, and I like bitter). I have no real taste for so much acids in food like lemon or ACV. I never liked pickles. My stomach burns easily.

If I NEED acid, then what sort of problem can I have in my stomach? Why those burns after using HCl?

I was great with vinegar and green and meat after a 1 week fast, then less good with using no vinegar during a few days, and having a bit more sugar... I have had stomach burn again, also some bloating due to having tried some starch again.

Those last 3 days better with meat and greens in lemon and vinegar. I stick with 1 betaine hcl per day when having meat.

But i have stomach burn developping in the hours AFTER. Especially while working in the garden. i was fine yesterday and carried stones, dug etc. BENDING = BURN.
 
Last edited:

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
So highish cholesterol and entire steroid pathway is downregulated. Have you had pregnenolone levels checked? Problem is either p450scc or 3b-HSD, and pregnenolone levels would tell us which it is. Since cholesterol is borderline high I am guessing p450scc, but if you are PFS than 3b-HSD is likely too. Could also be STAR protein limiting p450scc.

Easy treatment for upregulating p450scc or STAR protein would be eustress (something like IF/CR/exercise) + high dietary cholesterol intake + betaine HCl followed by high dietary protein intake. m_arch is following a similar plan and is having success (using just betaine HCl and IF/exercise/breathing exercises). I think high cholesterol and protein intake after 1-2 weeks would be a good idea as well.
Actually i crave / consume a lot of whole egg mayo. I bet thats high in cholesterol?

I also crave / consume a lot of protein, although mostly meat. But i am trying to get morr seafood in. Often mackerel or tuna with mayo and rice. My digestion has been bad the last 5 years or so. Earlier this year my doc said i had IBS (was getting stabbing pains) but TWY on raypeatforum suggested hcl witg meals. So i popped 3 caps with each meal for months. I must have gone through 750+ capsules 500mg each. Instantly my bowel movements turn perfect on HCL , like the next day.

Actually my symptoms sound a lot like @Admiral , despite eating a lot of protein and cholesterol i dont feel like i have high hormone levels. My hair test suspected high aldosterone levels (because of high sodium) but i havent had bloods done.

I just stopped taking hcl the last few months cos of the $$$, and i havent been needing it until lately. But i think part of the reason is that ive been on a diet that i know digests well for me, and ive had a few blowouts lately cos christmas.

@gbolduev did you say popping hcl for a long time wasnt a good idea? Whats the logic behind this?
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
I have fasted really long fasts, I measured ABG VBGs after on different refeeds. I see this situation completely differently.

I never go out of the fast on greens alone. one time I did that I put myself into crazy alkalosis. Green juices, greens are alkaline. And put you into alkalosis, same as drinking organic acids, like malic acid, citric, succinic. HCL, hydroniums are different it is a strong acid and instead of rising bicarbonate it will kill it.

People including me dont utilize Co2 properly, that is why we have compensation with met alkalosis. This is why when people eat less and eat greens this compensation gets even stronger. And then feel better. C02 production decreases and bicarbonate gets even higher.

the problem with HCL is that , HCL hits on this compensation very hard and lowers your potassium.


This is where the alkaline waters came around. Most people are with this Co2 problems, and alkaline waters basically do the same thing as greens in this respect. and breathing. They increase metabolic part of the compensation. Which increases potassium in the cell.

Zinc does the same.





Also HCL does nothing for the protein digestion. It is just a first step of breaking down protein. You need catalitic triad to even make the enzymes to get amino acids.

This is why in zinc finger protocol there is wobenzym. And catalitic triad aminos.

this is why I am asking not to use tons of HCL. it is worthless and will lower your thyroid effect.
 

Admiral

Well-Known Member
Messages
959
Wait, so I shouldn’t take the hcl? Or do I need to take it with something else? I’m confused a bit..
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
If you take HCL you need to take it with tons of food, and protein. and then eat something alkaline like green veggies.

You dont need to take tons of HCL, put one capsule in water and drink after you took your food . then wait some time, and then eat greens this way your potassium does not change much in the cell.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
acetaldehyde and acetic acid component of it to me NO GOOD.

This is the point what you are trying to fix. you are trying to lower acetaldehyde. and low acetylcholine activation. Thus no alcohol, no vinegars. Only kreb cycle end product could work. Even if you go with citric, I would be careful
I have no problems with malic acid though. ACV is just more accessible for most people.
ACV is the exact thing I would never use, EVER. it has acetaldehyde and acetic acid together which stops the break down of acetaldehyde.
Clinical proof: many people use it with good results!
I don't like ACV period. or any other vinegar. I think it kills the fast. That is my opinion, and I outlined why. You never want to take anything with acetaldehyde and acetic acid together. Since this is where 90% have their problem. IN acetaldehyde utilization.
Acetaldehyde is the precusor to acetic acid when making vinegar. But if the reaction is done properly then the bulk of that is converted to acetic acid. Then that is diluted with water even further to 5%. It's fine if you disagree. I don't think 1/2 tsp of ACV per day for a few weeks will harm anyone though.
I waited quite long after the fast before having any fruit at all, and I was having no starch at all. i am bad now due to my 1st intent to eat some starch....
I do not understand how I get energy form acetic acid! 1) I was doing it for the malic acid first, and it got rid of my gall bladder pain. Then 2) I want to increase acid.

I have always solved any stomach burn with ACV, and it works. Why?
Acetic acid is needed to make coenzyme A, along with cysteine and vitamin b5. then some of it goes to acetylcholine which we dont want. and some goes into the krebs cycle. This is why malic acid helps.

If you are not producing acetic acid in the body, you will feel more energy from acetic acid. This does not mean that it is doing you any good, since acetaldehyde is the limiting problem. Exactly, you took away acetic acid and increased acetaldehyde with fruits even more.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
So, I think I need more acid in my stomach, and that at the same time my stomach cannot stand to have more acid.

What can cause this sensitivity at stomach level?

What acid should I try?

If you are not producing acetic acid in the body, you will feel more energy from acetic acid. This does not mean that it is doing you any good, since acetaldehyde is the limiting problem. Exactly, you took away acetic acid and increased acetaldehyde with fruits even more.

Acetic acid is needed to make coenzyme A, along with cysteine and vitamin b5. then some of it goes to acetylcholine which we dont want. and some goes into the krebs cycle. This is why malic acid helps.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Yes I think histidine to lower histamine (increase stomach acid, increase amino absorption)
Nice loop some of us have to correct...
We need stomach acid to have amino absorption, so that we get enough histidine to lower excess histamine and increase stomach acid...

Going the free amino route is being discussed elsewhere.

Here I am interested to discuss increasing stomach acid, and also be able to stand it, as it seems that at least I have problem to increase it because it burns. I got some stomach burn the other morning, just from eating dandelion leaves.... I had to eat to just buffer this!
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Do you mean we can find the powder in bulk?
Do you mean that the same product makes a difference just by opening the capsule?

Mine is in tablets, is is Lamberts 324mg... it has even glycerin...

Then I have Good states in capsule, and I tolerate it less, it has650mg betaine hcl.... but less ingredients. ascorbyl palmitate and cellulose only.
 

TubZy

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
2,591
Do you mean we can find the powder in bulk?
Do you mean that the same product makes a difference just by opening the capsule?

Mine is in tablets, is is Lamberts 324mg... it has even glycerin...

Then I have Good states in capsule, and I tolerate it less, it has650mg betaine hcl.... but less ingredients. ascorbyl palmitate and cellulose only.

I just use this. I measure out 500mg and dump it into a big glass of water let it dissolve and drink it with a straw immediately after meals. I used to use capsules in the past but the effect is much much better doing it liquid way like gbol suggests. It works way quicker too.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00G..._SY340_QL65&keywords=betaine+hcl+powder&psc=1
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609

TubZy

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
2,591
Hrm I got up to 4 betaine hcl capsules (650mg) without noticing any burning or warmth. I'll try dumping it in water, see if that does anything.

Did/Do you have digestion issues at all? Yeah, try it in water and if still nothing try the pure powder. With the pure powder in water you should fill the effects within five minutes.
 

barbaar

Well-Known Member
Messages
807
Did/Do you have digestion issues at all? Yeah, try it in water and if still nothing try the pure powder. With the pure powder in water you should fill the effects within five minutes.

I have no apparent digestion issues, but gbold said that doesn't mean I'm actually digesting stuff properly. I tried dumping one capsule in water this evening and felt a little warmth soon after, but still nothing too noticeable.
 

TubZy

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
2,591
I have no apparent digestion issues, but gbold said that doesn't mean I'm actually digesting stuff properly. I tried dumping one capsule in water this evening and felt a little warmth soon after, but still nothing too noticeable.

Got it, yeah keep upping the HCL until you feel it slightly not not too much otherwise back down, maybe add in cysteine and histidine as well in the hcl form
 
Last edited: