MNK99
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 5,560
- Deleted by MNK99
The fact that reddit hates carnivore and keto and like... anything that makes sense, lifting, having high optimized hormones.. for any disease/ disorder and just says follow your doc and their UKRAINE-TRANS-supporting stuff makes me realize im on the rite path not doing anything at all like they do, regardless of the condition.
r/PCOS icon
Go to PCOS
r/PCOS
•
1 yr. ago
Wintersneeuw02
Why is there so much hate on this subreddit against veganism/plant based diets?
General/Advice
I got diagoned with PCOS when I was 20 in 2016, after years of several sympthoms. After about 8 months after that I decided to give eating vegan a try and this cleared up about 80% of all my PCOS sympthoms after about 2-3 months. 7 year later, I still eat vegan en still manage my PCOS, without any form of medication or hormonal birth control. I have seen several posts here filled with frustration, since nothing seems to work. Yet when I suggest opting for the vegan diet, I get downvoted into oblivion and get a lot of hatefull PMs. I thought this subreddit was to help others who suffer from PCOS and that is my intention aswell. Veganism is not a cure for everybody or for all the problems in the world, but is anything really? Especially reading the long lists of things many of rhe posters here have tried and failed to see any positive result, is me suggesting veganism really that weird?
Upvote
134
Downvote
124
comments
Share
Share
Add a comment
Sort by:
Best
Search Comments
Expand comment search
Comments Section
Pamplem0usse__
•
1y ago
I've legit never seen vegan/plant based hate on here. The only thing I ever see is that you MUST be keto, dairy free, gluten-free, and so miserable you lash out at everyone for being in proximity to a carb.
Upvote
335
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
AMaleManAmI
•
1y ago
I haven't noticed hate, but I have seen myself and others jumped on for not being 100% knowledgeable on the collective knowledge of carbs = devil. It's always been helpful and informative, with many being kind to others, but there is very much the beginnings of an echo chamber/cult of anticarbs.
I think it's because low & no carb has at least some scientific basis and it's worked wonders for a lot of people. PCOS has so little in the way of studies with solutions compared to other maladies that people grasp at what they can get.
Upvote
32
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
u/wenchsenior avatar
wenchsenior
•
1y ago
That is a wild exaggeration. I regularly comment on here noting that keto is not always necessary for people to manage their PCOS, and plenty of us regularly comment that being dairy free and gluten free is not based in robust science unless you have a known intolerance to them.
Upvote
24
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
Pamplem0usse__
•
1y ago
That's the point of my comment, it's an exaggeration because you do see people constantly posting about Keto, dairy free, gluten free as the only way and promoting this image of you have to be miserable with disordered eating to be thin and in remission.
People fear monger so much on this subreddit when it comes to carbs. I was making fun of the gospel constantly spewed around here.
Upvote
40
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
u/wenchsenior avatar
wenchsenior
•
1y ago
Ah, not enough coffee apparently. :takes big gulp:
Upvote
8
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
Pamplem0usse__
•
1y ago
S'allgood. Today was a Red Bull day for me.
Upvote
3
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
u/Infraredsky avatar
Infraredsky
•
1y ago
Yup - as someone who’s celiac I tell people this all the time…if it doesn’t help you’re actually hurting yourself by not eating gluten - gluten free things may be less processed but also tend to have less fiber
Upvote
5
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
5 more replies
[deleted]
•
1y ago
I haven't seen any hate for it here personally, but I know it's tiresome to hear about specific diets when that's not the root of the problem. Should we limit carbs and added sugar? Yes, everyone should. But that doesn't mean it'll "clear up" everyone's PCOS symptoms. Going vegan isn't going to fix my too high of testosterone.
Upvote
109
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
r/PCOS icon
Go to PCOS
r/PCOS
•
1 yr. ago
Wintersneeuw02
Why is there so much hate on this subreddit against veganism/plant based diets?
General/Advice
I got diagoned with PCOS when I was 20 in 2016, after years of several sympthoms. After about 8 months after that I decided to give eating vegan a try and this cleared up about 80% of all my PCOS sympthoms after about 2-3 months. 7 year later, I still eat vegan en still manage my PCOS, without any form of medication or hormonal birth control. I have seen several posts here filled with frustration, since nothing seems to work. Yet when I suggest opting for the vegan diet, I get downvoted into oblivion and get a lot of hatefull PMs. I thought this subreddit was to help others who suffer from PCOS and that is my intention aswell. Veganism is not a cure for everybody or for all the problems in the world, but is anything really? Especially reading the long lists of things many of rhe posters here have tried and failed to see any positive result, is me suggesting veganism really that weird?
Upvote
134
Downvote
124
comments
Share
Share
Add a comment
Sort by:
Best
Search Comments
Expand comment search
Comments Section
Pamplem0usse__
•
1y ago
I've legit never seen vegan/plant based hate on here. The only thing I ever see is that you MUST be keto, dairy free, gluten-free, and so miserable you lash out at everyone for being in proximity to a carb.
Upvote
335
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
AMaleManAmI
•
1y ago
I haven't noticed hate, but I have seen myself and others jumped on for not being 100% knowledgeable on the collective knowledge of carbs = devil. It's always been helpful and informative, with many being kind to others, but there is very much the beginnings of an echo chamber/cult of anticarbs.
I think it's because low & no carb has at least some scientific basis and it's worked wonders for a lot of people. PCOS has so little in the way of studies with solutions compared to other maladies that people grasp at what they can get.
Upvote
32
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
u/wenchsenior avatar
wenchsenior
•
1y ago
That is a wild exaggeration. I regularly comment on here noting that keto is not always necessary for people to manage their PCOS, and plenty of us regularly comment that being dairy free and gluten free is not based in robust science unless you have a known intolerance to them.
Upvote
24
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
Pamplem0usse__
•
1y ago
That's the point of my comment, it's an exaggeration because you do see people constantly posting about Keto, dairy free, gluten free as the only way and promoting this image of you have to be miserable with disordered eating to be thin and in remission.
People fear monger so much on this subreddit when it comes to carbs. I was making fun of the gospel constantly spewed around here.
Upvote
40
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
u/wenchsenior avatar
wenchsenior
•
1y ago
Ah, not enough coffee apparently. :takes big gulp:
Upvote
8
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
Pamplem0usse__
•
1y ago
S'allgood. Today was a Red Bull day for me.
Upvote
3
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
u/Infraredsky avatar
Infraredsky
•
1y ago
Yup - as someone who’s celiac I tell people this all the time…if it doesn’t help you’re actually hurting yourself by not eating gluten - gluten free things may be less processed but also tend to have less fiber
Upvote
5
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share
5 more replies
[deleted]
•
1y ago
I haven't seen any hate for it here personally, but I know it's tiresome to hear about specific diets when that's not the root of the problem. Should we limit carbs and added sugar? Yes, everyone should. But that doesn't mean it'll "clear up" everyone's PCOS symptoms. Going vegan isn't going to fix my too high of testosterone.
Upvote
109
Downvote
Reply
reply
Award
Share
Share