Breathe to increase CO2

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
In a nutshell, you can use Buteyko breathing, (used for asthmatic people who hyperventilate).
Now I do not understand why this breathing method is advised for everybody and improve any health condition!

You want to increase CO2 in 2 cases:
- on a daily basis, if You generally have too high blood CO2 = respiratory acidosis (@mattyB for confirmation)

- occasionally because CO2 helps to go into a more relaxed / parasympathetic state. It can help relax and sleep.

Our autonomic breathing pattern is regulated by the amount of CO2 in our blood. CO2 amount is what makes us inhale. (you could think it comes from lowered O2, but this is not the case). So we can think that our body inhales when it decides, according to the amount of CO2 it wants. As we can breathe consciously too, we can modify this.

At ANS level, we know that there is a relationship, and that inspiring activates the S-NS and expiring activates the PS-NS. If you breathe in and out long, you can clearly notice the change in breathing rythm: faster when you inhale and slower when you exhale. Before I knew this, I got afraid of having a heart problem because I had notice the variation! One more thing we should all be taught!!!

My idea is to make posts here about exercises that increase blood CO2....
 

tanedout

Well-Known Member
Messages
538
Quite a good overview of the Buteyko technique here;


Feels a bit unnatural, but definitely seems to have a calming effect!

This is interesting to see the background of the technique itself;

 

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Wow, wait a minute. am I sure that I am on hackstasis here?
Isn't what Buteyko is saying here exactly what peat and RPF are saying about CO2?

I thought here you are going with what gbolduev said about CO2, which is exacly the opposed:

CO2 increases metabolism LOL this is insanely WRONG

You want high CO2 production in the cell.meaning you want high metabolism in the cell . That means your breath it out fast and efficient. Only in this case body will allow your metabolism to be high in the cell. That is why sports people have high metabolism, since they breath out the CO2 faster they activate their sympathetic nervous system all the time.. And then if they quit sports and they eat the same excessive ammounts. They get fat. Since now their sympathetic nervous system is not active, but they eat tons of sugar and carbs and get fat and they go into acidosis from CO2, and body lowers potassium in the cell, this lowers thyroid signaling.

Peat says in the mountains high CO2 in blood. LOL

Mountains cause respiratory alkalosis. It is a proven fact.I lived in the mountains. body increases metabolism from this fact by lowering calcium and magnesium from the cell. That is why mountain people are often very skinny since the body allowes the metabolism to be lifted in the cell . Metabolism in the cell = CO2 production. If you cant get rid of CO2 properly , Metabolism will be LOWERED
I disagree with Peat on many aspects. As an example, living in the mountains and CO2. Did he live in the mountains? I did. You go into resp alkalosis and CO2 is low in blood since your hyperventilate looking for oxygen.

Actually most people have high CO2 not low in venous blood. Since most of them overeat on sugar, downregulate cortisol receptors and increase progersterone receptors, in this chemistry. 3 beta hsd which is zinc based will be suppressed and nad will be suppressed. This will cause your zinc to be biounavailable and you will be low on the CAD enzyme which converts CO2 into bicarb and will have high CO2. Also this will keep your methylation low , since NAD is needed to break down acetaldehyde and if acetaldehyde is high MAO will be inhibited . If MAO is inhibited methylation will be inhibited. This is how nicotinamide lowers histamine and serotonin.

No hairloss, I actually have long hair now.

Actually, 80 10 10 diet, caused a hairloss for me. HUGE ONE. I almost lost half of my hair on that stupid diet 6 years ag0 when I tried it. Sugar wastes zinc and manganese , needed for insulin, thus you get hairloss. Half of people on Peats diet lose the hell out of their hair. Like all of it. Since CO2 and sugar lowers your CO2 in the cell. You drink bubble water, that is a lot of CO2, body will compensate by lower your potassium in the cell. less potassium= less thyroid effect. Less CO2 produced in the cell. HAIRLOSS cure is to produce CO2 in the cell = high thyroid action. But this can be done only if you utilize your CO2 correctly. Lets say if you are missing adrenaline from undermethylation or your have problems with breathing and gas exchange. Taking in more CO2 as a gas and eating more sugar,, will lower your thyroid action in the cell. This should be understood. and I think this is the main misconcept in Ray Peat's theory.

One more time, for your thyroid to work and for you to produce high CO2 INSIDE OF THE CELL. You need to utilize this CO2 well, breathing it out or converting it to bicarbonate with zinc based enzyme. This is why the worst thing you can do is sit on your ass and eat a lot of carbs. This way, your sympathetic nervous system is not active and you don't breathe out CO2 properly , you sit at your computer all day. And if you eat a lot of sugars in this body chemistry, you will lose your hair, and you will get fat since your body will try to control the CO2 production inside of the cell by lowering potassium which switches off your thyroid action and this lowers your CO2 production inside of the cell.

Now for someone very active and with amazing sympathetic activity and methylation and good levels of zinc ( which converts that extra C02 into bicarbonate) your CO2 production will be high inside of the cell since you can utilize this CO2 properly . That is why cure for hairloss is zinc and manganese, these are 2 minerals which are low in it. This should be used instead of finasteride.

Short, if you want to have high co2 in the cell , you want to hyperventilate so you get rid of the co2 from the blood. High co2 in the blood makes cells to get rid of co2 .
 
Last edited:

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Good opportunity to explain what is not yet understood!
Things can be too low or too high, so there are always two opposite cases! Some people still NEED to up their CO2!
And you can sill NEED it from time to time, when you have hyperventilated because of stress and you want to calm yourself.

Wow, wait a minute. am I sure that I am on hackstasis here?
Isn't what Buteyko is saying here exactly what peat and RPF are saying about CO2?

I thought here you are going with what gbolduev said about CO2, which is exacly the opposed:

Short, if you want to have high co2 in the cell , you want to hyperventilate so you get rid of the co2 from the blood. High co2 in the blood makes cells to get rid of co2 .
So, what we are doing here is to not put everybody in the same shell. We are not doing the opposed of Peat, but stating that there are cases when increasing CO2 is not what we want. And sometimes yes... Peat and Buteyko are not wrong, they are just not taking some cases into account.
 

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Good opportunity to explain what is not yet understood!
Things can be too low or too high, so there are always two opposite cases! Some people still NEED to up their CO2!
And you can sill NEED it from time to time, when you have hyperventilated because of stress and you want to calm yourself.


So, what we are doing here is to not put everybody in the same shell. We are not doing the opposed of Peat, but stating that there are cases when increasing CO2 is not what we want. And sometimes yes... Peat and Buteyko are not wrong, they are just not taking some cases into account.
Make sense now . Thanks
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Make sense now . Thanks
Thanks for the opportunity to explain! ;) (and for the quick nice reaction...
am I sure that I am on hackstasis here?
...yes we are indeed in Hackstasis lol)

Actually, somebody asked for increasing CO2 and did not know Buteyko. That is why I started this thread. Thanks to TanedOut too!
A Buteyko exercise helped me several times, to BLOCK a coming headache. I would still use it in that case.

I had stopped Buteyko on a regular basis, because as he says, you get ill when you reach a CP of 30 seconds! Focal infections, fungi infections... It seems that is followers pass over this, but they also have to modify their eatings habits, and I guess they change metabolism with an increase in bicarbonate that comes to compensate the respiratory acidosis? @mattyb do I suppose right?

I have also modified the basic exercise, to make a new one that respect more the basics of the ANS. I just moved it to a separate thread, with a correct tittle.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
Yes, that is right. Compensation for respiratory acidosis is metabolic alkalosis (more bicarbonate).
 

tanedout

Well-Known Member
Messages
538
This is very interesting regards to low c02 in the blood, and resulting conditions;

Cardiovascular Symptoms
Hypocapnia reduces blood flow through vasoconstriction, or narrowed blood vessels. Reduced blood flow and bronchoconstriction, or narrowed bronchial tubes, reduces blood oxygenation. These characteristics of hypocapnia place excess pressure on the heart. Such cardiovascular pressure can lead to irregular heartbeats as well as angina pectoris, which is chest discomfort that increases in severity over time. Angina pectoris often causes extreme pain, and can lead to cardiac arrest. Sustained or recurrent hypocapnia can cause persistent cardiovascular disorders like heart disease.
Respiratory Alkalosis
According to "Behavioral and Psychological Approaches to Breathing Disorders," hypocapnia causes respiratory alkalosis, which is an elevation in blood pH. Respiratory alkalosis results in a reduction of serum calcium ions and arterial bicarbonate, which stimulates the sympathetic nervous system. Sympathetic stimulation caused by hypocapnia can result in numbness, dizziness, fainting, seizures, tingling sensations, paralysis, cold flashes and blurred vision, cumulatively known as neuronal irritability, or hyperirritability. As a result, doctors can mistake chronic hypocapnia for disorders with similar symptoms, like epilepsy.
Hypophosphatemia
"Neurology and General Medicine" indicates that hypocapnia causes sharp reductions of blood serum phosphate ions, clinically known as hypophosphatemia. This aspect of hypocapnia increases the likelihood of cardiovascular and respiratory difficulties because hypophosphatemia results in the destruction of red blood cells, further reducing oxygenation and causing damage that may persist even after treatment for hypocapnia. Other direct effects of hypophosphatemia include confusion, muscle weakness, heart damage, anemia, disorientation and coma.

https://www.livestrong.com/article/273319-the-indications-of-low-carbon-dioxide-in-the-blood/

This would explain the chest pain/chest tightness I experience. I also have very low phosphates and low potassium which again ties in with the above. I'm going to push for getting blood c02 tested next week, but if that comes back low then that would seem to confirm respiratory alkalosis as Gbol has suggested before.

I see a number of ways to increase c02 in blood;

- Resolve underlying issue (this might be related to be stuck in post-accutane/PFS type situation)​
- Breathing methods, Butyko method as Canari has pointed out, and this seems to have some effect​
- Exercise - the chest tightness I experience increased when I'm dormant as my desk at work, but is relived when going out for a 10 min + walk​
- Increase sodium bicarbonate levels in the blood. (understand just taking this will only neutralise stomach acid, but this product is designed so the capsule gets through the stomach and SB is released in the intestines to increase SB in the blood - thoughts on this anyone?! @gbolduev​
​
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
I see a number of ways to increase c02 in blood
Get candida! :eek:

"Respiratory alkalosis results in a reduction of serum calcium ions and arterial bicarbonate, which stimulates the sympathetic nervous system. Sympathetic stimulation caused by hypocapnia can result in numbness, dizziness, fainting, seizures, tingling sensations, paralysis, cold flashes and blurred vision, cumulatively known as neuronal irritability" :rolleyes:

They talk about sympathetic stimulation, but then mention a lot of FREEZE signs, which are parasympathetic OVER the sympathetic activation, when both system work together insead of alternately. Numbness, fainting, paralysis and cold are of parasympathetic dominance....
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
I found a good comment on a buteyko site:
(1st comment of this article )

"All we actually know is that slowing the breathing and pausing between breaths - AS IF we were calm, adrenaline-free and properly hydrated - corrects the problem of failed delivery of oxygen to the cells and does precisely ZERO to prevent the problem occurring in the first place."

ABSOLUTELY. We can control breathing, and the pause after exhale is para-sympathetic (rest & digest), and can induce it. But why would you want to spend your life in this state? Having a sympathetic activation IS automatic and HAVE TO be automatic, because quick can be life-saving!
That is why Buteyko breathing is good on occasions, even when you are one who does not beneficate form it regularly.

This person is a survivor and attributes it to his behaviour:

"my psychological calmness (lack of adrenaline response) [...] I am extremely intelligent and when things "happen", rather than panic, I go into a mode of observation, calculation, action and data-gathering. In other words, I'm psychologically intrigued, interested and engaged which is what makes me so handy to have around in an emergency but also tends to confuse and frighten people. And I say that because some of what I notice during such times is often "unbelievable" to others".

Even if he says that he has no adrenaline I think he is wrong, because interest in solving the emergency is part of activation, and adrenaline does not mean panic! He has activation, but can hold it! Big difference! In anxiety or panic, you cannot hold it... you cannot sustain the activation.