Calcium:Phosphorus Ratio in Diet

Messages
13
One of the 'health' principles i picked up from RPF was that one should ensure that a good diet should have a calcium:phosphorus ratio as close to 1:1 as possible.

I struggled to form a diet plan that stuck to this however. Short of drinking a gallon of milk each day or eating kg's of green vegetables it didn't seem possible. Considering how impractical it is in practice, the idea of a 1:1 ratio being optimal sounds odd to me.

Moving forward, is the 1:1 ratio ideal or is the optimal ratio more forgiving; or should the dietary Ca:p ratio be disregarded entirely?

Just as a sidenote; i wanted to thank you all for your contributions to this forum. I ordered a hair test a few months back because of this forum (attached for reference). I immediately ordered some Mag Chloride and felt much better within a week of supplementing.
 

Attachments

  • hairtest.png
    hairtest.png
    17.2 KB · Views: 22

Nina

Well-Known Member
Messages
960
Calcium isn’t as important as people say it is. If you only get 300-500 a day its completely fine. The phosphorus to calcium ratio doesn’t matter as much either, just try to eat in a balanced way
 
Last edited:

Nina

Well-Known Member
Messages
960
If you dont take into acc their Ca/P ratio (of Slow oxidation) as you say its not important, how then its clear they are in slow oxidation with almost border slow-fast Thyroid and fast Adrenals ratio ? Symptoms, cant fit well into RP Diet ?

They even state feel good on magnesium.




Your sodium is high in hair or magnesium is too low ?

Oh i looked at the hair test wrong. I thought it was just the minerals but it are the ratios. He isn’t a slow oxidizer
 
Messages
13
Calcium isn’t as important as people say it is. If you only get 300-500 a day its completely fine. The phosphorus to calcium ratio doesn’t matter either. As far as i can tell you are a slow oxidizer so you should stay away from calcium

Thank you for confirming this, I felt this might be the case, particularly as my hair test showed my Ca:p ratio as being higher than normal, in spite of the fact that i was not eating a 1:1 ratio at the time. It's just one of those bits of advice that I've held on to and has caused a bit of anxiety when trying to formulate workable meal plans.

It also didn't seem right as I've felt a large benefit from a high protein diet (more stable blood sugar), which obviously has a very high P:Ca ratio (without taking loads of egg whites)

If you dont take into acc their Ca/P ratio (of Slow oxidation) as you say its not important, how then its clear they are in slow oxidation with almost border slow-fast Thyroid and fast Adrenals ratio ? Symptoms, cant fit well into RP Diet ?

They even state feel good on magnesium.

Your sodium is high in hair or magnesium is too low ?

Magnesium is/was low. When I adjusted the ratio so that magnesium and calcium where in the correct ranges, the Na:Mg evens out more or less too.

Finally, just for a bit more context on the adrenal situation. I took this hair test 2 weeks before ending a very stressful 4 year relationship. My ex would trigger 5-10 adrenaline rushes each day due to her challenging behaviour. I believe that the Na:Mg ratio would have likely smoothed out a fair bit without magnesium supplementation.
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Calcium isn’t as important as people say it is. If you only get 300-500 a day its completely fine. The phosphorus to calcium ratio doesn’t matter either. As far as i can tell you are a slow oxidizer so you should stay away from calcium
Woah. Have you got your hair test back yet?

I think calcium is extremely important if in fast oxidation. Calcium to phosphorus is considered the thyroid ratio, pretty important if you ask dr. Peat LOL
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
One of the 'health' principles i picked up from RPF was that one should ensure that a good diet should have a calcium:phosphorus ratio as close to 1:1 as possible.

I struggled to form a diet plan that stuck to this however. Short of drinking a gallon of milk each day or eating kg's of green vegetables it didn't seem possible. Considering how impractical it is in practice, the idea of a 1:1 ratio being optimal sounds odd to me.

Moving forward, is the 1:1 ratio ideal or is the optimal ratio more forgiving; or should the dietary Ca:p ratio be disregarded entirely?

Just as a sidenote; i wanted to thank you all for your contributions to this forum. I ordered a hair test a few months back because of this forum (attached for reference). I immediately ordered some Mag Chloride and felt much better within a week of supplementing.
Can you show us the first graph with the individual mineral levels?
 

Nina

Well-Known Member
Messages
960
Woah. Have you got your hair test back yet?

I think calcium is extremely important if in fast oxidation. Calcium to phosphorus is considered the thyroid ratio, pretty important if you ask dr. Peat LOL

Calcium/potassium is the thyroid ratio according to hairtests. No need to obsess over calcium, plenty in diet and body will absorb what it needs. No need to force it
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Calcium/potassium is the thyroid ratio according to hairtests. No need to obsess over calcium, plenty in diet and body will absorb what it needs. No need to force it
Having underconsumed calcium due to a dairy intolerance for the last 18 years, im now finding increasing calcium foods to be hugely beneficial. I had low calcium on all my hair tests

There are no absolutes
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Individual mineral levels attached
Looks pretty good

Id suggest you cut back a bit on carbs (tends to push ca and na higher with too many) and maybe have some more magnesium foods.or a supplement
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Is cheese safe for slow oxis? Its technically not a supplement...
It provides calcium and sodium.

Good if you're a slow oxi with high magnesium, very bad if you have high calcium and low magnesium. Need to test.
 
Messages
13
Looks pretty good

Id suggest you cut back a bit on carbs (tends to push ca and na higher with too many) and maybe have some more magnesium foods.or a supplement

That's reassuring to hear as this was taken at what was probably my lowest ebb ever. I couldn't even drink a pint with friends without getting a panic attack (this went away within a week of leaving my ex btw, so was likely related to the constant adrenaline rushes and some psychological aspects).

I'll be sure to get a hair test soon to see where I stand now. I have been eating a 20:20:60 (fat:protein:carbs) diet for a while, but i suspect the benefits I've felt have mostly been due to me consciously eating at a surplus (i'm a little on the thin side). Would you recommend keeping fat% low and increasing protein intake instead?

What does this mean, are you saying you already corrected the ratios from this test confirmed by a re-test ? You were back in feb with border slow-fast thyroid and fast adrenals, even the graph doesnt look like slow oxidation , maybe they look quite different now. If that is your true pattern on hair you might actually need more calcium along magnesium than you think you need.

No i haven't corrected the ratios (as far as i'm aware). What i meant by that is that, my Na:Mg and Ca:Mg ratios where proportionally out of whack. I.e. if i corrected Ca:Mg ratio exclusively by raising Mg, it would also bring NA:Mg into a range. Obviously this is an overly simplistic view of things and I'll see about getting another hair test to see if i've moved everything in the right direction.
 
Last edited:

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
That's reassuring to hear as this was taken at what was probably my lowest ebb ever. I couldn't even drink a pint with friends without getting a panic attack (this went away within a week of leaving my ex btw, so was likely related to the constant adrenaline rushes and some psychological aspects).

I'll be sure to get a hair test soon to see where I stand now. I have been eating a 20:20:60 (fat:protein:carbs) diet for a while, but i suspect the benefits I've felt have mostly been due to me consciously eating at a surplus (i'm a little on the thin side). Would you recommend keeping fat% low and increasing protein intake instead?



No i haven't corrected the ratios (as far as i'm aware). What i meant by that is that, my Na:Mg and Ca:Mg ratios where proportionally out of whack. I.e. if i corrected Ca:Mg ratio exclusively by raising Mg, it would also bring NA:Mg into a range. Obviously this is an overly simplistic view of things and I'll see about getting another hair test to see if i've moved everything in the right direction.
For slow oxidisers is recommended 20% fat, 40% protein, 40% carbs. protein is supposed to be the most metabolically stimulating of all the macros, then carbs, and fats the slowest.

Just looking at your ratios now, you looked to have similar ratios to my first hair test (although yours isnt as bad as mine was!). Check it out here: https://hackstasis.com/threads/my-third-hairtest-w-comparison-25-7-18.1053/

BTW magnesium loss can be very acute i believe from adrenal stresses like leaving your ex. So the hair test is a 3 month window into what happened; you might have been much lower than your magnesium status indicates for a week or two (acutely low levels) but then it went back up when you started getting over the stress, which explains your problem drinking a pint.
 
Messages
13
For slow oxidisers is recommended 20% fat, 40% protein, 40% carbs. protein is supposed to be the most metabolically stimulating of all the macros, then carbs, and fats the slowest.

Just looking at your ratios now, you looked to have similar ratios to my first hair test (although yours isnt as bad as mine was!). Check it out here: https://hackstasis.com/threads/my-third-hairtest-w-comparison-25-7-18.1053/

BTW magnesium loss can be very acute i believe from adrenal stresses like leaving your ex. So the hair test is a 3 month window into what happened; you might have been much lower than your magnesium status indicates for a week or two (acutely low levels) but then it went back up when you started getting over the stress, which explains your problem drinking a pint.

Thank you for the feedback, i'll look into your post further. As I mentioned in my original post I've always felt better on a higher protein diet, but felt I had to keep it moderate due to my readings on RPF and my previous experience from a low carb diet.


Just to clarify, breaking up with my ex immediately reduced my stress levels and then again by the same factor when I moved out 3 weeks later. That's how bad the relationship was:). I'd been struggling with alcohol/anxiety and low desire for social interaction for over a year and both went away almost immediately.
 

supernature

Member
Messages
921
No i haven't corrected the ratios (as far as i'm aware). What i meant by that is that, my Na:Mg and Ca:Mg ratios where proportionally out of whack. I.e. if i corrected Ca:Mg ratio exclusively by raising Mg, it would also bring NA:Mg into a range. Obviously this is an overly simplistic view of things and I'll see about getting another hair test to see if i've moved everything in the right direction.


...
 
Last edited:

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Thank you for the feedback, i'll look into your post further. As I mentioned in my original post I've always felt better on a higher protein diet, but felt I had to keep it moderate due to my readings on RPF and my previous experience from a low carb diet.


Just to clarify, breaking up with my ex immediately reduced my stress levels and then again by the same factor when I moved out 3 weeks later. That's how bad the relationship was:). I'd been struggling with alcohol/anxiety and low desire for social interaction for over a year and both went away almost immediately.
Keep in mind even for a fast oxidation diet they recommend 33% protein, 33% fat, 33% carbs. Thats how important they think protein is.

Coming into hair testing, i was always a meat eating kinda guy. I craved it. But when i actually punched what i ate into cronometer, i only had like 15% protein. Waaaay under what i should of had. I think the nature of western society and everywhere for that matter as globalisation takes over, we eat a lot of cheap crappy processed carbs in general. Especially if we're big eaters, because meat and other nutrient dense foods are expensive.

My food bill has gone up a lot since doing hair testing lol, good nutrition costs $$$... unlike a sack of rice. I just try to buy bulk when i can and look for places that have the best per kg prices.