Can we post hair test results here for gbolduev to see?

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
My gf had a hairtest and it says shes a fast 4. However online the arl website says her ratios make her a slow oxidiser? We had the test done through trace elements
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
[mention]gbolduev[/mention]

I've done some more research. The hair test we did with Trace Elements, but it turns out they do different classifications.

So according to trace elements, she's a fast 4 (fast oxidiser with low thyroid / adrenals).
But if her hair is interpreted by ARL then she'd be considered a slow oxidiser.

She seems to demonstrate a lot more personality traits of a fast oxidiser (shes taken betablockers before cos she gets lots of adrenaline etc). She has a fast heart rate. LOTS of hair, in fact if anything her hairline is doing the opposite of receding lol

I think the difference is this: her calcium is lower than her phosphorus. in TE this means fast oxidiser
the ARL uses a different methodology. i think its the calcium related to potassium ratio. shes's a slow oxidiser based on that

What are your thoughts gbolduev?

Thanks
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Can sb explain the scaling please? If the center is the balanced metabolism, which fast and which slow are the closer to each other? The 1 or the 4?

(It is a big problem if they do not agree, as it makes it less trustworthy.... 2 men working together -Eck and Watts- and then separate, and then 2 labs with 2 readings that are so different? I hope only the words are different, after all they are arbitrary categories and what counts are the numbers and what you advise to do with them.)
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Canari post_id=749 time=1507539053 user_id=62 said:
Can sb explain the scaling please? If the center is the balanced metabolism, which fast and which slow are the closer to each other? The 1 or the 4?

(It is a big problem if they do not agree, as it makes it less trustworthy.... 2 men working together -Eck and Watts- and then separate, and then 2 labs with 2 readings that are so different? I hope only the words are different, after all they are arbitrary categories and what counts are the numbers and what you advise to do with them.)
In trace elements you want to be a fast 1 or a slow 1. fast 4 and slow 4 are the furtherest from optimal
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Ok, if 1 is near balance, slow 4 is the slowest oxidizer, and fast 4 the fastest oxydizer?
Waoo, if your gf is fast 4, she is the furthest from slow, and she would be called slow by the other lab??
Confusing!
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Here are the results:

https://ibb.co/bDZQMG
https://ibb.co/g4EEFb

g4EEFb

bDZQMG


What should she do [mention]Gbolduev[/mention] ??? Slow oxidiser or fast oxidiser plan? Eat like ray peat says??
 

Orion

Well-Known Member
Messages
879
m_arch post_id=1175 time=1507859588 user_id=66 said:
Here are the results:

https://ibb.co/bDZQMG
https://ibb.co/g4EEFb

g4EEFb

bDZQMG


What should she do @Gbolduev ??? Slow oxidiser or fast oxidiser plan? Eat like ray peat says??

I know we are trying to move away from oxidation types, but that hair test is slow:
Slow oxidation is defined on a hair mineral analysis as a calcium/potassium ratio greater than 4 and a sodium/magnesium ratio less than 4.17. The higher the calcium/potassium ratio or the lower the sodium/magnesium ratio, the slower the oxidation rate.

Also looks close to 4 Lows, but they are not all below value, gbolduev mentioned is one of the bad states to be in. http://www.arltma.com/Articles/AllFourLowDoc.htm

I think he would suggest fasting, and eating the way he does, seafood, rice, etc... avoid calcium and copper. And lots of exercise.
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Orion post_id=1219 time=1507900325 user_id=56 said:
m_arch post_id=1175 time=1507859588 user_id=66 said:
Here are the results:

https://ibb.co/bDZQMG
https://ibb.co/g4EEFb

g4EEFb

bDZQMG


What should she do @Gbolduev ??? Slow oxidiser or fast oxidiser plan? Eat like ray peat says??

I know we are trying to move away from oxidation types, but that hair test is slow:
Slow oxidation is defined on a hair mineral analysis as a calcium/potassium ratio greater than 4 and a sodium/magnesium ratio less than 4.17. The higher the calcium/potassium ratio or the lower the sodium/magnesium ratio, the slower the oxidation rate.

Also looks close to 4 Lows, but they are not all below value, gbolduev mentioned is one of the bad states to be in. http://www.arltma.com/Articles/AllFourLowDoc.htm

I think he would suggest fasting, and eating the way he does, seafood, rice, etc... avoid calcium and copper. And lots of exercise.

Yeah slow according to ARL , its fast according to TEI. They use phosphorus instead of potassium to work out the metabolic rate
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Instead of trying to move away from oxidation types, shouldn't we try to dig in further, to be more precise than a mere dichotomy?

And if anybody understand where is the difference between the 2 labs... I cannot believe that ALL their fasts and slows are the reverse one from the other, but only a specific case. Maybe ask them both to answer this!
 

Orion

Well-Known Member
Messages
879
m_arch post_id=1223 time=1507901001 user_id=66 said:
Orion post_id=1219 time=1507900325 user_id=56 said:
m_arch post_id=1175 time=1507859588 user_id=66 said:
Here are the results:

https://ibb.co/bDZQMG
https://ibb.co/g4EEFb

g4EEFb

bDZQMG


What should she do @Gbolduev ??? Slow oxidiser or fast oxidiser plan? Eat like ray peat says??

I know we are trying to move away from oxidation types, but that hair test is slow:
Slow oxidation is defined on a hair mineral analysis as a calcium/potassium ratio greater than 4 and a sodium/magnesium ratio less than 4.17. The higher the calcium/potassium ratio or the lower the sodium/magnesium ratio, the slower the oxidation rate.

Also looks close to 4 Lows, but they are not all below value, gbolduev mentioned is one of the bad states to be in. http://www.arltma.com/Articles/AllFourLowDoc.htm

I think he would suggest fasting, and eating the way he does, seafood, rice, etc... avoid calcium and copper. And lots of exercise.

Yeah slow according to ARL , its fast according to TEI. They use phosphorus instead of potassium to work out the metabolic rate

Ah yes this is confusing... definitely interested to see gbolduev thoughts. Hoping he gets around to his big post on types and thoughts on protocols.
 

Georgia

Member
Messages
6
m_arch post_id=755 time=1507561512 user_id=66 said:
Canari post_id=749 time=1507539053 user_id=62 said:
Can sb explain the scaling please? If the center is the balanced metabolism, which fast and which slow are the closer to each other? The 1 or the 4?

(It is a big problem if they do not agree, as it makes it less trustworthy.... 2 men working together -Eck and Watts- and then separate, and then 2 labs with 2 readings that are so different? I hope only the words are different, after all they are arbitrary categories and what counts are the numbers and what you advise to do with them.)
In trace elements you want to be a fast 1 or a slow 1. fast 4 and slow 4 are the furtherest from optimal

Hi m_arch thanks for your posts and I thought it was the other way around.

Meaning more optimal to be a Slow 4 or Fast 4 ??
Do you have any info that shows it is more optimal to be a Fast 1 or a Slow 1.
I have been looking on this forum and may have missed it.

I tested as a Slow 1 seven years ago and will do another round of tests and curious to see for any changes.

Did you use InterClinal Labs?
TIA
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Georgia post_id=1643 time=1508218510 user_id=118 said:
m_arch post_id=755 time=1507561512 user_id=66 said:
Canari post_id=749 time=1507539053 user_id=62 said:
Can sb explain the scaling please? If the center is the balanced metabolism, which fast and which slow are the closer to each other? The 1 or the 4?

(It is a big problem if they do not agree, as it makes it less trustworthy.... 2 men working together -Eck and Watts- and then separate, and then 2 labs with 2 readings that are so different? I hope only the words are different, after all they are arbitrary categories and what counts are the numbers and what you advise to do with them.)
In trace elements you want to be a fast 1 or a slow 1. fast 4 and slow 4 are the furtherest from optimal

Hi m_arch thanks for your posts and I thought it was the other way around.

Meaning more optimal to be a Slow 4 or Fast 4 ??
Do you have any info that shows it is more optimal to be a Fast 1 or a Slow 1.
I have been looking on this forum and may have missed it.

I tested as a Slow 1 seven years ago and will do another round of tests and curious to see for any changes.

Did you use InterClinal Labs?
TIA

Hi Georgia,

Sorry I was confused. It is more optimal to be a slow 4 or fast 4. Yes I used interclinical labs.
I did a post about this here: http://hackstasis.com/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=108

As you can see my gf has some minerals high for a fast, some high for a slow. I think this is why I was confused, also why she is a 4. If someone is clearly and definitively a slow they will most likely be a 1 or 2. I think the most dominant ratio determining if a person is slow or fast is the calcium to phosphorous ratio.


It seems that Trace Elements (interclinical labs in australia) has better info than ARL, although they are not that different.
 

Georgia

Member
Messages
6
m_arch post_id=1647 time=1508221213 user_id=66 said:
Georgia post_id=1643 time=1508218510 user_id=118 said:
m_arch post_id=755 time=1507561512 user_id=66 said:
In trace elements you want to be a fast 1 or a slow 1. fast 4 and slow 4 are the furtherest from optimal

Hi m_arch thanks for your posts and I thought it was the other way around.

Meaning more optimal to be a Slow 4 or Fast 4 ??
Do you have any info that shows it is more optimal to be a Fast 1 or a Slow 1.
I have been looking on this forum and may have missed it.

I tested as a Slow 1 seven years ago and will do another round of tests and curious to see for any changes.

Did you use InterClinal Labs?
TIA

Hi Georgia,

Sorry I was confused. It is more optimal to be a slow 4 or fast 4. Yes I used interclinical labs.
I did a post about this here: http://hackstasis.com/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=108

As you can see my gf has some minerals high for a fast, some high for a slow. I think this is why I was confused, also why she is a 4. If someone is clearly and definitively a slow they will most likely be a 1 or 2. I think the most dominant ratio determining if a person is slow or fast is the calcium to phosphorous ratio.


It seems that Trace Elements (interclinical labs in australia) has better info than ARL, although they are not that different.

Cheers m_arch
Thought that was the case.
Well it will be interesting to see if my profile has changed at all. Anything significant I shall post.
Again thanks for your quick response and for the link/post you attached. I used InterClinicals first time round and will stay with them.
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Georgia post_id=1650 time=1508224061 user_id=118 said:
m_arch post_id=1647 time=1508221213 user_id=66 said:
Georgia post_id=1643 time=1508218510 user_id=118 said:
Hi m_arch thanks for your posts and I thought it was the other way around.

Meaning more optimal to be a Slow 4 or Fast 4 ??
Do you have any info that shows it is more optimal to be a Fast 1 or a Slow 1.
I have been looking on this forum and may have missed it.

I tested as a Slow 1 seven years ago and will do another round of tests and curious to see for any changes.

Did you use InterClinal Labs?
TIA

Hi Georgia,

Sorry I was confused. It is more optimal to be a slow 4 or fast 4. Yes I used interclinical labs.
I did a post about this here: http://hackstasis.com/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=108

As you can see my gf has some minerals high for a fast, some high for a slow. I think this is why I was confused, also why she is a 4. If someone is clearly and definitively a slow they will most likely be a 1 or 2. I think the most dominant ratio determining if a person is slow or fast is the calcium to phosphorous ratio.


It seems that Trace Elements (interclinical labs in australia) has better info than ARL, although they are not that different.

Cheers m_arch
Thought that was the case.
Well it will be interesting to see if my profile has changed at all. Anything significant I shall post.
Again thanks for your quick response and for the link/post you attached. I used InterClinicals first time round and will stay with them.
No worries. Are you doing a retest after some changes? I'm interested to see how it goes. It will usually take at least 3 months for changes to show up in the hair
 

esp90

Well-Known Member
Messages
203
m_arch post_id=1175 time=1507859588 user_id=66 said:
Here are the results:

https://ibb.co/bDZQMG
https://ibb.co/g4EEFb

g4EEFb

bDZQMG


What should she do @Gbolduev ??? Slow oxidiser or fast oxidiser plan? Eat like ray peat says??


Did you get an answer from gbolduev about what she should do? my test is VERY similar to your gfs...
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
esp90 post_id=6007 time=1512504058 user_id=1394 said:
m_arch post_id=1175 time=1507859588 user_id=66 said:
Here are the results:

https://ibb.co/bDZQMG
https://ibb.co/g4EEFb

g4EEFb

bDZQMG


What should she do @Gbolduev ??? Slow oxidiser or fast oxidiser plan? Eat like ray peat says??


Did you get an answer from gbolduev about what she should do? my test is VERY similar to your gfs...

No