How to eat? Timing of meals etc...

bruschi11

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
3,011
One thing that has crossed my mind recently as I'm about to break this fast is how we should eat. There are so many opinions out there...

You hear "3 meals a day- breakfast, lunch, dinner. Don't snack or only 1 snack a day." Or "intermittent fast (IF)- only eat lunch and dinner and snack that night."

You also hear "Eating every two hours is great and speeds your metabolism. 6-8 small meals a day is what is healthiest for your body."

I believe IF is only for those with great genetics maybe without health issues. In the past, it worked horribly for me as it chewed up muscle. The alternative day fasting (ADF) technique where you fast from 24 to 48 hours once a week or so is something that I practice and believe in. The benefits of ADF are substantial.

Anyways, fasting aside- for your normal day I'm left with two obvious, but quite different options: 3 times a day normal meals, or eat smaller meals continuously throughout the day?
 

joekool

Moderator
Messages
551
Hey Bruschi11

The real question is, how many times a day should we drink?

Just kidding... but seriously... 6 to 8 small meals burned through muscle for you?? Were you lifting weights regularly during that time? Primarily protein focused?? I hate to think it was catabolic so let us know...

I honestly tell people very simply under 2 scenarios :

Want to lose weight? Eat 6 300 cal meals. This works out to be every 3 hours. 1800 cals a day.

Want to gain weight? Eat 6 600 cal meals. Every 3 hours. 3600 cals a day.

For both diets, I say no more soda or juices or even gum in between meals as it starts the digestive process (releases small amount of stomach acid) and you *may* not be hungry when your 3 hours is up. The gain is for weight lifters though... focusing on protein but fats are acceptable for obviously reasons.. good fats...

Sumo wrestlers eat twice a day... 10000 cals each for the ultimate in slow metabolism ... so you're right when you say multiple meals for higher metabolism but I'm shocked it was catabolic for ya... let me know what you were eating and doing??
 

bruschi11

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
3,011
joekool post_id=3935 time=1510347321 user_id=75 said:
Hey Bruschi11

Just kidding... but seriously... 6 to 8 small meals burned through muscle for you?? Were you lifting weights regularly during that time? Primarily protein focused?? I hate to think it was catabolic so let us know...

I think you misunderstood me a bit. I should have been more clear I guess. I lost muscle while continuously intermittent fasting- where I wouldn't eat until noon then till 8pm each day. The 16 hour window thing. This has nothing to do with amount of meals eaten per day. Just the window.

6 to 8 small meals is what I prefer to do and eating breakfast literally IMMEDIATELY. This is what I plan to do post-fast, but I'm just really asking the question if 3 larger meals would be more beneficial. It is definitely a topic of debate because I know a lot of disease advocates will advise on eating only 3 times per day.
 

joekool

Moderator
Messages
551
Oh you're right ... i missed the IF in your sentence...

Are you hitting the gym?

I may have a lot to learn because fasting seems to trigger some magic but I don't like IF to be honest... and so then it's a question of what your dietary needs are... if your'e hitting the gym, you definitely need, for example, more protein than someone else.

So if you were to ask "How much protein should I take?"... the answer is 'It depends'... I kinda feel food intake timing is the same. You have the breakfast idea right on the money... as you're breaking a fast upon waking... when I was trying to put on weight, I would set an alarm to wake me up at 2:30am to drink a 1000 cal protein shake... so as to NOT go 8 hours without food.

But using my sumo wrestler example, 3 larger meals would mean more possible stored as fat depending on the size of meal... again, if you aren't hitting the gym, 3 may suffice... if you are and find yourself with a larger appetite & need a steady stream of protein, I'd go with 6 meals... fyi, that's what I do... actually I aim for 7... but i'm just saying so this advice isn't coming from someone who doesn't practice what he preaches...
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
I am slow and I was going mad by eating fruits all day, needed to eat all the time!
Here are the advises, though they say to eat more often too... If I eat a lot of proteins, I can handle more apart meals. Also Ithink we have to take into account our digestive issues.
 

Attachments

  • Captura de pantalla de 2017-11-10 23-17-38.png
    Captura de pantalla de 2017-11-10 23-17-38.png
    121.4 KB · Views: 61