Let's drop the idea of oxidizers

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Canari post_id=3100 time=1509443355 user_id=62 said:
mattyb post_id=3090 time=1509413126 user_id=95 said:
I don't really care about types. You'll know if fasting is good for you once you try it. I feel great just not eating for half the day, and if I'm relaxing I can easily go an entire day without feeling a dip in energy levels. It's easy to know if my body needs it based off of how I tolerate it.

People speak of types as if it's set in stone. It isn't. I can stimulate my metabolism so it behaves like my girlfriend's by simply not eating and drinking some coffee while exercising (so I can go from a "slow" to a "fast" in the span of 20 hours). I hate this slow and fast dichotomy. I read through ARL's description of slow and fast and I fit about 50% of each category. I think it's a stupid dichotomy and should be largely ignored.

Metabolism is transient and always changing. Trying to pin it down with one broad categorization will only do you a disservice. I think we are better off defining ourselves by our symptoms, our behaviours, our environment, and any lab results all within context of each other.
Matty, I agree it is stupid to think sth is set in stone, or only a dichotomy. Nevertheless, I think we should see more branches than the 2 big ones, and not prune the tree!

As you say, you can stimulate your metabolism, to be like your girlfriend who does not need this stimulation. Fast or slow may also be bad names, as they are analogies with the common meaning.

As @m_arch says, you can feel slow when you are ill, and it is momentaneous but this is not for me the meaning of slow and fast.

I also fit in a certain % of slow and fast definitions/symptoms, but I know to what it is related in my nervous system, as there are cases, @gbolduev confirmed it when I asked. You can have S and SP on at the same time.

More over, when you know yourself, you can do the necessary to balance yourself, and we have to admit that those tips do not have the same result for everybody, or are useless for some. Everything in life moves like waves, even electricity ondulates, and everything moves in a pendulating way. If you go too much on one side, you have the pendulum going stronger in the opposite direction, and that is what gbolduev uses in contrarian endocrinology too.

We cannot drop the idea of oxidizers, we can refine it so that people do not feel stuck in one camp or another and gain flexibility.
I agree. I think we should keep the oxidiser types as a base. As gbolduev said, theyre not likely to change as a baseline.[mention]mattyb[/mention] you said this too i believe, that slow oxidisers are likely to have 'strong' organs over others, different organ strengths to fast oxidisers (as a baseline)
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
You are welcome to use whatever dichotomy you want to describe these things, but to me they are meaningless because I haven't yet heard an actual physiological explanation for what makes fast/slow oxidizer. The only thing defining it is a cluster of symptoms and some hair tests, which to me, says that it isn't understood at all. Just saying things like "fast oxidizer is high energy and has a high ratio P/Ca" doesn't actually describe the physiological mechanism of oxidation and metabolism. If it was defined as people with a certain set of genetic polymorphisms, mtDNA, or mitochondrial behavior or something (and this was reflected in hair tests) I could get behind that more, because those would describe the actual rate of oxidation in physiological terms.

For example, let's say a person presents with muscle pain and fatigue and gets diagnosed with fibromyalgia. Is that any help? No, not really, since there is no physiological definition of the condition, and no treatment. You may as well have been diagnosed with something from a fairy tale and told to figure it out yourself. You gain nothing from the label other than maybe some peace of mind from the fact that the symptoms aren't caused by something like cancer that'll kill you.

My explanation of the organ thing wasn't based around slow/fast oxidizer, but around acidosis vs. alkalosis - which is a definable and measurable pattern with clear physiological explanations and clear treatments. In acidosis and alkalosis there are nuances - many things affect how acidic/alkaline the blood is (multiple buffer systems), there are different types of acidosis and alkalosis, etc. There is nuance when the physiological mechanisms at the deepest levels are understood and used as defining characteristics, which gives us real information. I don't see that in the ARL system - I don't see nuance, I just see a blunt instrument.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
mattyb post_id=3114 time=1509457836 user_id=95 said:
You are welcome to use whatever dichotomy you want to describe these things, but to me they are meaningless because I haven't yet heard an actual physiological explanation for what makes fast/slow oxidizer.

My explanation of the organ thing wasn't based around slow/fast oxidizer, but around acidosis vs. alkalosis - which is a definable and measurable pattern with clear physiological explanations and clear treatments. In acidosis and alkalosis there are nuances - many things affect how acidic/alkaline the blood is (multiple buffer systems), there are different types of acidosis and alkalosis, etc.
First we need to go out of dichotomy with the subtypes, and of course remember it is a code and no more. The map is not the territory and the tree divides in endless branches.

I think there is a parallel with acidosis and alkalosis and I think [mention]gbolduev[/mention] said it too. I think he said a slow oxi has too much co2 (but where...) and was in a state of acidosis.

Who remembers or has quote from him?
 

Clementine

Member
Messages
18
Canari post_id=3131 time=1509468374 user_id=62 said:
mattyb post_id=3114 time=1509457836 user_id=95 said:
You are welcome to use whatever dichotomy you want to describe these things, but to me they are meaningless because I haven't yet heard an actual physiological explanation for what makes fast/slow oxidizer.

My explanation of the organ thing wasn't based around slow/fast oxidizer, but around acidosis vs. alkalosis - which is a definable and measurable pattern with clear physiological explanations and clear treatments. In acidosis and alkalosis there are nuances - many things affect how acidic/alkaline the blood is (multiple buffer systems), there are different types of acidosis and alkalosis, etc.
First we need to go out of dichotomy with the subtypes, and of course remember it is a code and no more. The map is not the territory and the tree divides in endless branches.

I think there is a parallel with acidosis and alkalosis and I think @gbolduev said it too. I think he said a slow oxi has too much co2 (but where...) and was in a state of acidosis.

Who remembers or has quote from him?

This quote (there are others) is from the long post "Gbol Quotes & Ideas":
As generalization, people can be divided into fast and slow oxidizers. Fast oxidizers are the minority. These do good on Ray Peats diet, which is heavy on copper, calcium and sugar.
Slow oxidizers retain Co2, and lack sympathetic nervous system they are overloaded with copper and calcium and will never do good on these.

It was my understanding also that his categories were based on acidosis v. alkalosis. I seem to remember he said that he uses the hair test to create his own system, rather than using ARL's, and that was what he was planning to share with everyone before the big ban.