Low stomach acid or something else?

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
Hello.

Basically my stomach feels super bloated 24/7. I can not take a full satisfying breath.. i feel like something is constricting my breathing. I do not know if it is an indicator for something but i like spicy and acidic foods. I have gerd from time to time but it is mild. I usually get a short burning sensation for around couple of seconds. No pains , gas, constipation or indigestion. Do you think despite the lack of usual symptoms that i may need more stomach acid?

I read that this can be also a symptom of heart failure and this is scary. I also have constant chest discomfort.

Any ideas or suggestions? Sadly i do not have a gastroenterologist in my city so i can not when i can get checked.

Thanks
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
When my father had some pain in his chest, he did not relate it to stomach acidity at all, and he had this maybe once per month. I have had some gerd only with eating loads of fruits and especially bananas and coconut oil for dinner: would wake up at night to sit up, and then go for cider vinegar and that was gone.

I have tried betaine hcl but never needed more than 1 per meal. Then I could not stand it and stopped it. But maybe this came from sensitive stomach after a long time with low acid?

I hated acid taste! This is changing little by little...

And I had finally concluded that my acid was ok.... until hair test. Well, I need more HCl yes! So you see, it is not always very visible. Have you done or planned hair test? Or can you guess you are fast or slow oxidizer with the informations some of us who did it gave? Can you envisage to do a fast? That would give a rest to your stomach...

Also, on the net you find home test for stomach acid, like the baking soda test, easy to look for.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
[mention]mattyb[/mention] gave a tip with breakfasting with bitter herbs and cider vinegar, which I do too.

i find surprising that you have no gas if you are bloated!
 

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
Maybe the word bloat is not the right choice .... but i definatelly feel that something is constricting my breathing in the abdominal area
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
galio23 post_id=5201 time=1511793714 user_id=1395 said:
Maybe the word bloat is not the right choice .... but i definatelly feel that something is constricting my breathing in the abdominal area
All the time? Maybe you have a problem with the muscle diaphragm! In that case, digestion is not bad, but the mere volume of food makes the problem!

Do you also have some back pain bellow omoplates? Like the lower ribs on the back.

How is it when you focus on your breathing and make deep slow breathes. Do you feel some blockage then? Focus on the sensation of your lungs, filling with air, and notice your shoulders go up and also the lower part pushing down. Can you do both well or do you feel your shoulders lift better than your lungs push your organs down?

The respiratory diaphragm is supposed to massage our organs when we inhale, by pushing them down. This is why the diaphragmatic breathing is supposed to make bellly comes out on inhale... And at the same time the ribs expand also in the back and upward, lifting the shoulders. All makes sense in giving room to our lungs, to have a good gas exchange.

Take some time to feel how it all feels there and tell us!
galio23 post_id=5104 time=1511711054 user_id=1395 said:
I read that this can be also a symptom of heart failure and this is scary. I also have constant chest discomfort.
... gastroenterologist
Is a gastroenterologist the right specialist if you fear for your heart? What does say a general doctor about it and did you see a specialist about heart?
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
How old are you? Any history of aneurysms or cardiovascular disease in the family? Overweight/underweight? Is it worse after eating? What happens when you fast for a while?
 

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
25 years old, my father and grandmother have heart problems. I am currently 260lb but i felt like this when i was at 190lb so i doubt it is weight related.

Yeah it is worse after eating and worst after eating and sitting.

The only form of fasting that i have ever done is intermittent fasting and i got slightly better.

I just ordered some Chromium Polynicotinate and if it fails to bring benefits i will try some D-ribose.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
You are young, very low chance it is anything heart related. You can always get an echo done though if you are really worried, and maybe a 24-hour halter monitor. If it will ease your mind it is worth it IMO.

Lose weight. It will take pressure off the diaphragm. I would start contemplating a doing a longer fast (or a series of smaller ones) to accomplish this, as it will likely help with digestion if that is the issue.

Start practicing diaphragmatic breathing.

Try out the ACV + EVOO + Greens combo to improve digestion. Do it first thing in the morning on an empty stomach and then fast for a ~2 hours afterwards. Do this for 1-2 weeks straight to see if you notice a difference.

These are really simple things you can try out, especially the last two. I would try those out before screwing with any supplements, you are just risking putting your body in further imbalance with any supplements, especially if you do not 100% understand the ramifications of whatever supplement you take actually does in your body.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
Oh and one last thing - you may want to get an x-ray or an ultrasound to make sure you don't have a hatial hernia. That's another important thing to rule out.
 

tanedout

Well-Known Member
Messages
538
galio23 post_id=5104 time=1511711054 user_id=1395 said:
Hello.

Basically my stomach feels super bloated 24/7. I can not take a full satisfying breath.. i feel like something is constricting my breathing. I do not know if it is an indicator for something but i like spicy and acidic foods. I have gerd from time to time but it is mild. I usually get a short burning sensation for around couple of seconds. No pains , gas, constipation or indigestion. Do you think despite the lack of usual symptoms that i may need more stomach acid?

I read that this can be also a symptom of heart failure and this is scary. I also have constant chest discomfort.

Any ideas or suggestions? Sadly i do not have a gastroenterologist in my city so i can not when i can get checked.

Thanks

You can check mean cell haemogoblin levels to get an indication of heart failure (high would suggest this), but I would say it's unlikely to be that. My levels were actually on the high side recently as I've had absolutely tanked potassium and phosphate levels. Still unsure exactly why, but supplementing with potassium and high phosphate foods (milk primarily) seems to have helped. Getting some more bloods done tomorrow (interestingly it turns out alkalosis would tank both). Could be worth getting your potassium tested, but when mine was really low you could feel that the contractions of your heart muscles were not quite right.

Pretty sure I have issues with stomach acid, and I notice if I supplement with betaine HCI I get much better mental clarity afterwards (take it with a meal). You could try that and see how you get on.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Yes I also think the hernia must be ruled out...
Canari post_id=5209 time=1511798577 user_id=62 said:
How is it when you focus on your breathing and make deep slow breathes. Do you feel some blockage then? Focus on the sensation of your lungs, filling with air, and notice your shoulders go up and also the lower part pushing down. Can you do both well or do you feel your shoulders lift better than your lungs push your organs down?

The respiratory diaphragm is supposed to massage our organs when we inhale, by pushing them down. This is why the diaphragmatic breathing is supposed to make belly comes out on inhale... And at the same time the ribs expand also in the back and upward, lifting the shoulders. All makes sense in giving room to our lungs, to have a good gas exchange.

Take some time to feel how it all feels there and tell us!
Diaphragmatic breathing is good to do, but only has benefit if you do it properly and feeling what you do. Thus I have repeated my questions. They are meant to help you feel how it goes for you, and to check out what you feel and what not. Before modifying breathing, you should feel what you actually already do!
 

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
Thank you all for the good asnwers.

When i try to do some yoga style breathing i actually feel the need to yawn and still feel the constriction in my abdomen.

The reason i feel it is heart related is because i feel chest pressure and again difficulty breathing when lying on my back.

I will try betaine HCL soon. Do you think i may need it even if i do not have any digestive problems?
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
[mention]galio23[/mention] you should see a doctor and ask for those tests, to be sure, and to KNOW, which is better than doubts!

Yawning means you change nervous state and go toward para-sympathetic, this is a good sign that what you do is good for you. Can you go into details about experimenting feeling the movements of your muscles for breathing? Can you do the movement of "pushing" down your organs? Does your belly increase size went you breathe in, and reduces when you breathe out?

For betaine hcl, there are tests on the web, to know if you need it. If you just try, take 1 and with a neat meal, a it is especially useful with protein.
 

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
I am wondering how thiamine HCL compares to bataine HCL... because i tried larged doses of thiamine HCL and got no improvements.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
galio23 post_id=5391 time=1511935487 user_id=1395 said:
I am wondering how thiamine HCL compares to bataine HCL... because i tried larged doses of thiamine HCL and got no improvements.

Thiamine HCl is not the same at all, doesn't do the same thing. Betaine HCl is what you want.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
galio23 post_id=5338 time=1511900106 user_id=1395 said:
Thank you all for the good asnwers.

When i try to do some yoga style breathing i actually feel the need to yawn and still feel the constriction in my abdomen.

The reason i feel it is heart related is because i feel chest pressure and again difficulty breathing when lying on my back.

I will try betaine HCL soon. Do you think i may need it even if i do not have any digestive problems?

Then get the heart tests done, any doctor will do them if you say you feel chest pain because they have to for liability reasons.

But just know that the chest pressure doesn't mean heart. You could have costochondritis, rib sublaxations, slipping rib syndrome, there are many many causes of chest pressure. I have had costochondritis myself and still suffer from it on occasion. I went through all of these tests and stuff - and I can assure you it gave me huge peace of mind to know that my heart was okay.
 

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
Not really. Just some general discomfort in the heart area. It also get worse when i lie down. When i relax i feel like something is closing and i get this sharp inhales during the night. I was never officially diagnosed with sleep apnea but i am sure i have it.
 

galio23

Well-Known Member
Messages
47
No pain. Also it get worse when i lie down and relax. Feels like something relax too much in my chest. I was never tested for sleep apnea but i am 95% i have it. I am pretty sure that the stomach restriction is due to being overweight .

Other related/unrelated symptoms:
Brain problems ( brain fog , depression, memory problems)
Thinning hiar
Dandruff
Some weird prostate/erection problems
Slight Roscea
Slight GERD from time to time
Weird sinus problems.