Osteoarthritis caused by zinc supplementation ?

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
At the beginning of the year, after few blood tests that suggested that I have zinc in the in the lower range of the reference range, I decided to supplement with zinc sulfate to help with my hair-loss. I started to supplement with high doses, even 3 times higher than the daily recommended dose which I think it's around 10 mg a day.

After a while, I remember when I first started to experience pain in my left knee , in the meantime of an physical exercise for legs... where knees were under pressure.

At the time I have not take this seriously, thinking that it's just something that will be gone soon, because I never had serious knee problems or pain in the past.

Then after a while the pain started to be more and more present especially when I was walking for long distances, and knees was under pressure, and the pain appeared for the both of the knees. With time, my pain started to be more aggressive and soon I was into a situation where I could not even walk without pain, or move properly and freely. In the beginnings I was thinking that this is caused by the cold weather ... it was winter and I stayed a lot in cold weather sometimes without being dressed properly for under 0 Celsius Temperatures . In all that time I was under zinc supplementation. After a while I started to think about if zinc it's not causing this problem. So I started to research a bit on internet and I have come to your research papers starting with this: Regulation of the Catabolic Cascade in Osteoarthritis by the Zinc-ZIP8-MTF1 Axis - ScienceDirect and this Загрузка статьи , and soon I understood that I probably I was destroying my knees cartilages with this zinc supplementation not even realizing or being aware of such a consequence. I was shocked and I immediately stoped supplementing zinc, but I think to late... after months supplementation with high doses of zinc. My pain and impossibility to walk got worse and worse.



How might the human wound-healing response be manipulated to resemble the superhealer phenomenon? Kim et al. speculate that local depletion of zinc, inhibition of ZIP8 function and zinc influx and inhibition of MTF1 activity in cartilage might be effective therapeutic approaches. Indeed, inhibiting the target of zinc, the matrix metalloproteases, has long been considered a logical treatment strategy. Although early attempts at metallo- protease inhibition suffered from a lack of selectivity and were associated with musculoskeletal side effects11, more-selective metalloprotease inhibitors are showing promising therapeutic potential11, as are strategies for inhibiting the zinc–ZIP8–MTF1 axis .In all such studies, it will be important to consider the broader effects of zinc on the body. Might zinc supplementation in humans worsen osteoarthritis? And is it feasible to lower zinc levels in a joint without affecting systemic zinc availability? For successful therapeutic targeting, we will also need to fill gaps in our understanding of the molecular basis of osteoarthritis. What are the initial events that upregulate ZIP proteins in cartilage? And how is IL-1β, the inducer of ZIP8, itself induced?





In my desperate situation, Because I understood that I should get rid of zinc, I ordered Calcium EDTA and I started to take 1.2 Grams sublingual /day for better absorption to chelate zinc from the body. I don't know if this is effective or not to stop my pain, and to heal, but I have to give it a try... but I have to be careful because it's not local depletion of zinc, but depletion in the whole body... If there are any way I could deplete zinc only locally in the knees please let me know. I am willing to do whatever it's necessary to save my knees and restore the possibility of walking freely without pain.

I have also started also to supplement with Olive Leaf Extract 1 gram a day, based on this Therapeutic Effects of Olive and Its Derivatives on Osteoarthritis: From Bench to Bedside. - PubMed - NCBI , Olive leaf extract prevents cartilage degeneration in osteoarthritis of STR/ort mice. - PubMed - NCBI ... which suggests that OLE has the potential to prevent cartilage degeneration in Osteoarthritis . Also I take eggs shell membrane.



I would really appreciate if you have any advice for my situation in stoping the degeneration of my cartilages and stoping the pain, and recovering. If you can advice me on what i should do in order to deplete zinc locally, please let me know.

Also, if you have any advice on what I should take or supplement, or what I should not do in regard to my sublingual and oral intake of Calcium EDTA.

Thank you


jul 24 update : Magnetic resonance imaging says I have Meniscus Lesions on both of my knees . Read here: https://hackstasis.com/threads/osteoarthritis-caused-by-zinc-supplementation.961/post-26046
 
Last edited:

Slayo

Well-Known Member
Messages
534
Zinc should never be taken alone.
You can test copper and if not high take it as well as using histidine, if copper is high you need manganese and histidine
 

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Zinc should never be taken alone.
You can test copper and if not high take it as well as using histidine, if copper is high you need manganese and histidine

Copper can't be high, since my blood tests before starting zinc sugested that it;s very low actually . Box
I started to take some copper here and there.
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
"Copper can't be high, since my blood tests before starting zinc sugested that it;s very low actually"


Do you realize that copper number from the blood means nothing? What about your ceruloplasmin? This issue is discussed here over and over and over again. True copper deficiency is very rare. So it is not about copper deficiency, but about cofactors and your bio chemistry if the body can use the copper that is most likely stored in the liver or spilled in the brain etc.. On the other hand zinc, magnesium, manganese, boron, molybdenum etc. deficiency is very common. But copper is virtually in every type food + absorption of copper is much easier for the body than other minerals..
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
Zinc should never be taken alone.
You can test copper and if not high take it as well as using histidine, if copper is high you need manganese and histidine
So why I have low copper in the blood/hair and ARL gives me high doses of zinc without copper?
 

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Guys, I was saying that copper can't be high ... after being on high dosa of zinc. Zinc chelates copper ,and reduce hardly copper absorption.. right ? Of course serum copper, is not tissue copper, but since i think i am fast oxidizer.. For sure i'am in a case where i need copper... not where i am full of it...
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
Guys, I was saying that copper can't be high ... after being on high dosa of zinc. Zinc chelates copper ,and reduce hardly copper absorption.. right ? Of course serum copper, is not tissue copper, but since i think i am fast oxidizer.. For sure i'am in a case where i need copper... not where i am full of it...
Is there any good evidence for this? Zinc will block copper absorption in the intestine for sure(if there is good amount of zinc with copper at the same time). But I don't see much evidence that zinc will chelate copper from the body once is copper already absorbed.. Also if you really need copper. I don't see any reason for taking copper in supplement form? There is so many foods rich in copper. You can have something like 5 mg a day from regular diet very easy.. This is not a case for other minerals like boron, manganese, molybdenum or even zinc. That is a good reason why to take minerals like this in supplement form, but not copper..
 

supernature

Member
Messages
921
Calcium EDTA and I started to take 1.2 Grams sublingual /day for better absorption to chelate zinc from the body. I don't know if this is effective or not to stop my pain, and to heal, but I have to give it a try... but I have to be careful because it's not local depletion of zinc, but depletion in the whole body...


...
 
Last edited:

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Also I want to point out another problem that i had before even started zinc. At 09.27.17 my RBC was 5.97 with ranges 4.3 -5.7 , my HCT was 52.6 with ranges 39-49 and my HGB was 17.2 with ranges 13.2 - 17.3. Newer blood tests from 6/11/18 : RBC was 6.05 with ranges 4.3 -5.7 , my HCT was 52.9 with ranges 39-49 and my HGB was 17.2 with ranges 13.2 - 17.3 .
What causing this problem ? I would really apreciate for any sugestions or opinion .

@mattyb and @Helen I would really apreciate guys if you can help me or point me into something with all these problems .

Thank you
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
Zinc in high doses can act to inhibit aromatase, lowering estrogen. You need estrogen to to keep copper active and going to places like joint repair. Stop the zinc immediately, and wait. You may want to eat more copper rich foods while waiting for aromatase to kick back in. Be easy on your joints during that time. Estrogen will come back online soon (assuming you aren't PFS or anything, because if that is the case than it's more complicated than that). Don't take creatine or anything either, it can inhibit aromatase (this means reduce the amount of red meat you are eating). You may want to eat more phytoestrogens (in beans, legumes, etc.), or take some resveratrol in pulsed doses (e.g. not every day, maybe 2-3 times per week) to get estrogen sensitized and working again.

Your blood test results indicate dehydration and possibly CO2 retention. Do maximal exhalation breathing exercises regularly to clear out CO2 (or low impact steady state cardio for +45 minutes as often as possible), and drink more water + electrolytes. That should normalize RBC/HCT/HGB. This may be related to the joint problems, since high HCT will cause issues with blood flow to the joints. But I think the primary cause of joint issues is aromatase inhibition from zinc.

I don't think EDTA is necessary. I would stop that. It's just going to cause more problems because it chelates a bunch of stuff. Just eat more copper rich foods, eat foods that contain phytoestrogens, minimize dietary zinc, avoid red meat (contains zinc and creatine), breathe more, and consistently drink more water with some electrolytes. Then be easy on the joints for the time being, and wait for aromatase to come back online. The joint pain will clear up eventually.

I get joint pain when I supplement with creatine. I've gone through something similar in the past. It will take several months before you start feeling better because joints heal slowly. If you can regularly get blood flow to the affected joints (use things like heat, red light, sleeves, pain-free movement, etc.) it will help significantly. Blood flow to the joints is the biggest hurdle to tackle when healing joint injuries.
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
"I started to supplement with high doses, even 3 times higher than the daily recommended dose which I think it's around 10 mg a day."
3x10mg is 30mg of zinc. That is "high" amount of zinc? I think it is not high amount of zinc enough to act as AI. Especially when you consider that you will not absorb 100% of it.. Maybe like 70%..
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
"I started to supplement with high doses, even 3 times higher than the daily recommended dose which I think it's around 10 mg a day."
3x10mg is 30mg of zinc. That is "high" amount of zinc? I think it is not high amount of zinc enough to act as AI. Especially when you consider that you will not absorb 100% of it.. Maybe like 70%..

It depends on the person. If they are low in copper and estrogen already, and not depleted in zinc, then 30mg/day for ~6 months is a lot of excess zinc. Many guys will report joint and bone side effects from 100-150mg/day of zinc after as little as a week (0.7-1g of zinc). Consuming over 16 grams of zinc in 6 months is a ton, especially if it's not balanced. Additive effects are important to consider, in addition to individual factors.
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
It depends on the person. If they are low in copper and estrogen already, and not depleted in zinc, then 30mg/day for ~6 months is a lot of excess zinc. Many guys will report joint and bone side effects from 100-150mg/day of zinc after as little as a week (0.7-1g of zinc). Consuming over 16 grams of zinc in 6 months is a ton, especially if it's not balanced. Additive effects are important to consider, in addition to individual factors.
What you think about my hair test pls ? They recommend like 75 mg of zinc a day.. I am taking 30 mg capsule a day for now since I have no idea if I am deficient or toxic in copper lol.. + my blood copper was always low and ceruloplasmin also lower..
http://hackstasis.com/threads/yura-hair-test-finally-here.921/
 

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Zinc in high doses can act to inhibit aromatase, lowering estrogen. You need estrogen to to keep copper active and going to places like joint repair. Stop the zinc immediately, and wait. You may want to eat more copper rich foods while waiting for aromatase to kick back in. Be easy on your joints during that time. Estrogen will come back online soon (assuming you aren't PFS or anything, because if that is the case than it's more complicated than that). Don't take creatine or anything either, it can inhibit aromatase (this means reduce the amount of red meat you are eating). You may want to eat more phytoestrogens (in beans, legumes, etc.), or take some resveratrol in pulsed doses (e.g. not every day, maybe 2-3 times per week) to get estrogen sensitized and working again.

Your blood test results indicate dehydration and possibly CO2 retention. Do maximal exhalation breathing exercises regularly to clear out CO2 (or low impact steady state cardio for +45 minutes as often as possible), and drink more water + electrolytes. That should normalize RBC/HCT/HGB. This may be related to the joint problems, since high HCT will cause issues with blood flow to the joints. But I think the primary cause of joint issues is aromatase inhibition from zinc.

I don't think EDTA is necessary. I would stop that. It's just going to cause more problems because it chelates a bunch of stuff. Just eat more copper rich foods, eat foods that contain phytoestrogens, minimize dietary zinc, avoid red meat (contains zinc and creatine), breathe more, and consistently drink more water with some electrolytes. Then be easy on the joints for the time being, and wait for aromatase to come back online. The joint pain will clear up eventually.

I get joint pain when I supplement with creatine. I've gone through something similar in the past. It will take several months before you start feeling better because joints heal slowly. If you can regularly get blood flow to the affected joints (use things like heat, red light, sleeves, pain-free movement, etc.) it will help significantly. Blood flow to the joints is the biggest hurdle to tackle when healing joint injuries.

@mattyb
Thank you . I also have deviated sept , so probably i don't breathe properly... so very possible that i have co2 retention also.
I stopped taking zinc. This pain started in Jan/ February and since then it's getting worse and worse, at the begining I haven't even assumed that it's from zinc , but i was thinking that it's from cold... staying in cold temperature.. and continuing to take zinc... Then i found out about those papers that talk about how zinc and it's transporter zip8 and then MTF 1 and matrix-degrading enzymes are destroying the cartilages. And how they used Calcium EDTA to reverse all this and to block these matrix-degrading enzymes.

I am taking EDTA 1.2 grams a day sublingual... because of this..

The ZIP8-mediated increase in Zn2+ influx was abolished by the cell-impermeable metal ion chelator, calcium-saturated EDTA (CaEDTA), or the cell-permeable chelator, N,N,N’,N’-tetrakis (2-pyridylmethyl) ethylenediamine (TPEN) (Figure 1C). IL1β, which increased both transcript and protein levels of ZIP8 (Figure 1A, inset), caused an influx of Zn2+ in chondrocytes that was blocked by downregulating Zip8 with small interfering RNA(siRNA) or the metal ion chelators CaEDTA or TPEN (Figure 1C)
......
We therefore asked whether cellular Zn2+ influx driven by ZIP8 is sufficient to cause expression of matrix-degrading enzymes. Among the examined enzymes, MMP3, MMP9, MMP12, MMP13, and ADAMTS5 were significantly upregulated by infection of chondrocytes with an adenoviral Zip8 expression construct (Ad-Zip8); this effect was blocked by metal ion chelation with CaEDTA or TPEN (Figure 2A)
.....
Among the ZIP8-regulated matrix-degrading enzymes, MMP3, MMP13, and ADAMTS5 are crucial effectors of OA cartilage destruction (Blom et al., 2007, Glasson et al., 2005, Little et al., 2009). Indeed, upregulation of these enzymes by IL1β was abolished by knockdown of Zip8 with specific siRNA or by metal ion chelation with CaEDTA or TPEN (Figures 2E and 2F)

....
. Notably, adenoviruses expressing mouse Mtf1 (Ad-Mtf1) infection significantly upregulated expression of matrix-degrading enzymes (MMP3, MMP9, MMP12, MMP13, and ADAMTS5), an effect that was abolished by CaEDTA or TPEN

The article it's long but worth reading .
I was thinking for a bit to apply EDTA topical on my knees... I am desperate at this point and don't know what i am doing or what I should do. I just heard today how my left hip was Popping on movement...


About Estrogen and probably inhibition of Aromatase, this is interesting. I have googled a bit and found this study , Estrogen-related receptor γ causes osteoarthritis by upregulating extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes , where they say that Estrogen-related receptor gamma, Estrogen-related receptor γ causes osteoarthritis by upregulating extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes, those enzymes that destroy cartilage , and that are unregulated by zinc-zip8-mf1 axis too .

It is possible that this receptor to be upregulated because Estrogen it's low, to force it to come back ?or i have no idea what i am talking about...it's exacly the oposed . If this receptor it's upregulated, it should not be high Estrogen ?

In this study, we used human OA cartilage and mouse models of OA to investigate whether ERRs are associated with OA pathogenesis. Here, we report that ERRγ is a novel catabolic regulator of OA pathogenesis. We found that, among the ERR family members, ERRγ was specifically upregulated in cartilage from human OA patients and various mouse models of OA. Our gain-of-function (adenovirus-mediated overexpression in joint tissues or Col2a1-Esrrg Tg mice) and loss-of-function (Esrrg +/– mice or shRNA-mediated knockdown) approaches clearly indicated that ERRγ acts as a novel catabolic regulator of OA pathogenesis, at least in part, by the upregulating matrix-degrading enzymes, MMP3 and MMP13, in articular chondrocytes.


I am taking Copper suplement, is this fine, or should i focus on food instead of supplementing ?
I am kind of desperate at this point, i can't walk properly , i am in pain when i walk... not even talking about putting presure on knees... but just walking. And i don't really understand exactly what 's happening, not even talking about knowing what to do to fix it/
 
Last edited:

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
What you think about my hair test pls ? They recommend like 75 mg of zinc a day.. I am taking 30 mg capsule a day for now since I have no idea if I am deficient or toxic in copper lol.. + my blood copper was always low and ceruloplasmin also lower..
http://hackstasis.com/threads/yura-hair-test-finally-here.921/

Have you written about your symptoms anywhere? Need to see history + symptoms + tests to have any clue what to do.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
@mattyb
Thank you . I also have deviated sept , so probably i don't breathe properly... so very possible that i have co2 retention also.
I stopped taking zinc. This pain started in Jan/ February and since then it's getting worse and worse, at the begining I haven't even assumed that it's from zinc , but i was thinking that it's from cold... staying in cold temperature.. and continuing to take zinc... Then i found out about those papers that talk about how zinc and it's transporter zip8 and then MTF 1 and matrix-degrading enzymes are destroying the cartilages. And how they used Calcium EDTA to reverse all this and to block these matrix-degrading enzymes.

I am taking EDTA 1.2 grams a day sublingual... because of this..



The article it's long but worth reading .
I was thinking for a bit to apply EDTA topical on my knees... I am desperate at this point and don't know what i am doing or what I should do. I just heard today how my left hip was Popping on movement...


About Estrogen and probably inhibition of Aromatase, this is interesting. I have googled a bit and found this study , Estrogen-related receptor γ causes osteoarthritis by upregulating extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes , where they say that Estrogen-related receptor gamma, Estrogen-related receptor γ causes osteoarthritis by upregulating extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes, those enzymes that destroy cartilage , and that are unregulated by zinc-zip8-mf1 axis too .

It is possible that this receptor to be upregulated because Estrogen it's low, to force it to come back ?




I am taking Copper suplement, is this fine, or should i focus on food instead of supplementing ?
I am kind of desperate at this point, i can't walk properly , i am in pain when i walk... not even talking about putting presure on knees... but just walking. And i don't really understand exactly what 's happening, not even talking about knowing what to do to fix it/

Honestly man, you are over-thinking this big time. That Zip8 paper isn't really applicable to your situation. They used a virus to activate estrogen receptors, zinc influx, and MMP activation. This isn't your case at all. It's also osteoarthritis - there are many forms of joint degeneration that aren't osteoarthritis. Your issue is joint pain. We do not have confirmed evidence of joint degeneration for you yet either.

I wouldn't supplement copper, no. I would get everything you need from food. Always try to avoid supplements or medications whenever possible because they are harder to regulate and come with stronger and unexpected side effects. Stop taking EDTA, it will just fuck you up in unexpected and unpredictable ways - you can treat what you have without it, with low risk interventions that will just take a bit longer.

More phytoestrogens, more dietary copper, less dietary zinc, less dietary creatine, more blood flow to the knees, more glycine/collagen supplements, breathe out that CO2 with breathing exercises or low-intensity, low-impact cardio. That's what you need to focus on to get the joints better.

I don't know much about you so I don't want to make specific dietary recommendations regarding calcium and stuff like that because it could screw you up in other ways.
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
Have you written about your symptoms anywhere? Need to see history + symptoms + tests to have any clue what to do.
Yeah I wrote my "story" somewhere. Besides taking accutane all kinds of steroids etc.. I think my health problems started when I was 12-13 yo when I had amalgams placed in my mouth. Everything from bad digestion, leaky gut, severe acne, delayed puberty, depression , brain fog, later high TSH and bad hypothyroidsm etc.. Anyway I will continue on recommended micronutrients + chlorella and will see what will change on another test.. Btw I have CRAZY detox symptoms just from 2mg of iodine from lugol's solution. Do you think that iodine is strong mercury chelator?
 

hello

Well-Known Member
Messages
66
Honestly man, you are over-thinking this big time. That Zip8 paper isn't really applicable to your situation. They used a virus to activate estrogen receptors, zinc influx, and MMP activation. This isn't your case at all. It's also osteoarthritis - there are many forms of joint degeneration that aren't osteoarthritis. Your issue is joint pain. We do not have confirmed evidence of joint degeneration for you yet either.

I wouldn't supplement copper, no. I would get everything you need from food. Always try to avoid supplements or medications whenever possible because they are harder to regulate and come with stronger and unexpected side effects. Stop taking EDTA, it will just fuck you up in unexpected and unpredictable ways - you can treat what you have without it, with low risk interventions that will just take a bit longer.

More phytoestrogens, more dietary copper, less dietary zinc, less dietary creatine, more blood flow to the knees, more glycine/collagen supplements, breathe out that CO2 with breathing exercises or low-intensity, low-impact cardio. That's what you need to focus on to get the joints better.

I don't know much about you so I don't want to make specific dietary recommendations regarding calcium and stuff like that because it could screw you up in other ways.
Thank you . I would start focus on eating .. liver, seeds, beens .. Mushrooms.stuff like this..

You right i don't have evidence that my cartilages are destroyed, all i know it's that i can't walk without pain at both of my knees. I am thinking to have an IRM for one knee to know for sure where i am.