Sources of manganese

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Food sources are better than supps!

Sea food:
  • Mussels, clams, bass and trout.

Bad news if you are not fond of working out and burn your PUFAs, seeds are very good sources.
From more to less:
  • pine nuts, hazelnuts, poppy, pumpkin, flax, macadamia, almonds, sesame, hemp

Grains:
  • Teff, oats, brown rice, wheat, quinua, buckwheat

Spices are quite high though we do not eat that much...
  • Clove, cinnamon, cardamom, curcuma and garlic.

Legume are quite fair:
  • Lima, winged beans, garbanzos and adzuki, soy

Greens:
  • spinach, amaranth, tetragone. Beet and swiss chard

Fruits - fair amounts in some tropical fruits:
  • Pineapple, mango, papaya
Also berries.

Tea contains a lot, but if you want to get a good quantity, only instant tea will give a fair amount, 47%DV instead of 3% DV in a cup.
Coffee and cacao also bring manganese. Then you have molasses and maple syrup. And sea salt.
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
As the web gives you either how much there is in a cup, 1 oz, 100grams, or any indefinite "serving", it is difficult to quote and rate food.
You would get your 2mg of manganese with:
  • 1oz mussels
  • 6oz bass or trout
  • 2oz / 56g macadamia
  • 3/4 cup of pineapple juice
  • between 1 and 2 cups for greens
  • 50g cocoa powder/chocolate
(but high in copper)
  • 3-4g of clove
  • 4 cups of brewed tea

If you do not avoid starches and PUFAs:
  • 45g pumpkin seeds
  • 20g pine nuts
  • 1 cup lima or winged beans
  • 1 cup of brown rice or quinua

Rice bran is really high, but we would have to know the effects of the bran anti-nutrients...
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
Start with a green salad with crunchy macadamia, pineapple and garlic
Go on with mussels and broccoli with rice according to exercise...
(Please eat your included-in-any-recipe-from-now-on cloves... :mrgreen: )
Then a good coffee with cardamom and cinnamon and a big piece of dark chocolate!

And be wise with your pineapple juice if you are a slow! :lol:

Be English at 5pm: a cup of tea.
 

PhilParma

Member
Messages
13
Manganese

<r>There's been lots of talk about zinc + manganese lately. Zinc is easily obtained via oysters. However, oysters are also very high in copper and only moderately high in manganese. How should we get more manganese in the diet without relying on trashy supplements? I tried drinking Dole concentrated pineapple juice but it upset my gut a bit. I eat sourdough bread daily. I don't know if I'm getting enough manganese. I want to protect my hair.<br/>
<br/>
<SIZE size="150"><s></s>How are you guys getting manganese?<e></e></SIZE></r>
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Re: Manganese

<t>I think rice has it</t>
 

ruprmurdoch

Well-Known Member
Messages
470
Re: Manganese

<t>how manganese affect hormones ? I mean: cortisol, testosterone, dht,estradiol,lh,fsh, acth, dhea, insulin</t>
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Re: Manganese

<r><QUOTE author="ruprmurdoch" post_id="1064" time="1507767752" user_id="83"><s>
ruprmurdoch post_id=1064 time=1507767752 user_id=83 said:
</s>
how manganese affect horones ? I mean: cortisol, testosterone, dht,estradiol,lh,fsh, acth, dhea, insulin
<e>
</e></QUOTE>

I think it increases dht</r>
 
Messages
9
Re: Manganese

<r><QUOTE author="PhilParma" post_id="1046" time="1507761045" user_id="134"><s>
PhilParma post_id=1046 time=1507761045 user_id=134 said:
</s>
There's been lots of talk about zinc + manganese lately. Zinc is easily obtained via oysters. However, oysters are also very high in copper and only moderately high in manganese. How should we get more manganese in the diet without relying on trashy supplements? I tried drinking Dole concentrated pineapple juice but it upset my gut a bit. I eat sourdough bread daily. I don't know if I'm getting enough manganese. I want to protect my hair.<br/>
<br/>
<SIZE size="150"><s></s>How are you guys getting manganese?<e></e></SIZE>
<e>
</e></QUOTE>

<br/>
My n=1 is that oysters always gave me net estrogenic symptoms. I suspect it's because of its high copper content. Calf liver is similarly problematic.</r>
 

PhilParma

Member
Messages
13
Re: Manganese

<t>Well then maybe Ray Peat is right and oysters don't need to be taken more than once a month. I ate oysters today for lunch and then my libido tanked into the evening. Contrary to popular wisdom, oysters don't do much to increase my libido.<br/>
<br/>
If anyone does have a manganese supplement that they are confident in, feel free to share it. I'm just afraid of impurities and excipients. Rice and pineapple juice might just be the way to go.</t>
 

TubZy

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
2,591
Re: Manganese

<r><QUOTE author="PhilParma" post_id="1070" time="1507771219" user_id="134"><s>
PhilParma post_id=1070 time=1507771219 user_id=134 said:
</s>
Well then maybe Ray Peat is right and oysters don't need to be taken more than once a month. I ate oysters today for lunch and then my libido tanked into the evening. Contrary to popular wisdom, oysters don't do much to increase my libido.<br/>
<br/>
If anyone does have a manganese supplement that they are confident in, feel free to share it. I'm just afraid of impurities and excipients. Rice and pineapple juice might just be the way to go.
<e>
</e></QUOTE>

nutrabio has a solid one (no expedients and high quality)</r>
 

PhilParma

Member
Messages
13
I've started taking the Nutrabio manganese that you suggested TubZy. Is anyone worried about manganese toxicity from supplementation? 10-20mg per day is safe?
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
PhilParma post_id=2181 time=1508544090 user_id=134 said:
I've started taking the Nutrabio manganese that you suggested TubZy. Is anyone worried about manganese toxicity from supplementation? 10-20mg per day is safe?
What is not safe is to answer your question... Any isolated mineral can be unsafe, depending on the balance of your personal body with other minerals! You can read the general threads that are about balance or context.
I also recommend to feel your body sensations and notice if something changes.
 

tanedout

Well-Known Member
Messages
538
Fennel seeds are a very good source of manganese. I've just got some fennel tea because fennel has anti-progesterone properties and I wanted to try some things that are gentle (it also smells exactly like licorice so could have similar properties), but check out the manganese content;
Nutritional value per 100 g (3.5 oz)
Energy 1,443 kJ (345 kcal)
Carbohydrates
52 g
Dietary fiber 40 g
Fat
14.9 g
Saturated 0.5 g
Monounsaturated 9.9 g
Polyunsaturated 1.7 g
Protein
15.8 g
Vitamins
Thiamine (B1) (36%) 0.41 mg
Riboflavin (B2) (29%) 0.35 mg
Niacin (B3) (41%) 6.1 mg
Vitamin B6 (36%) 0.47 mg
Vitamin C (25%) 21 mg
Minerals
Calcium (120%) 1196 mg
Iron (142%) 18.5 mg
Magnesium (108%) 385 mg
Manganese (310%) 6.5 mg
Phosphorus (70%) 487 mg
Potassium (36%) 1694 mg
Sodium (6%) 88 mg
Zinc (42%)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fennel#Uses

Pumpkin seeds are a good source too, but they're also really high in zinc which may not be ideal
 

Canari

Member
Messages
1,609
tanedout post_id=2234 time=1508584930 user_id=523 said:
Fennel seeds are a very good source of manganese. I've just got some fennel tea because fennel has anti-progesterone properties
Manganese (310%) 6.5 mg
Pumpkin seeds are a good source too, but they're also really high in zinc which may not be ideal
Yes, fennel is estrogenic.
You need a lot to get Mang.
Pumpkin seeds are very good.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
One cup of oats. There's 120% your RDA right there.

Add in rice, black beans, and some veggies and you are up over 200% easily. It's so easy to get high amounts of manganese.
 

Yura

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,471
As the web gives you either how much there is in a cup, 1 oz, 100grams, or any indefinite "serving", it is difficult to quote and rate food.
You would get your 2mg of manganese with:
  • 1oz mussels

  • 6oz bass or trout

  • 2oz / 56g macadamia

  • 3/4 cup of pineapple juice

  • between 1 and 2 cups for greens

  • 50g cocoa powder/chocolate
(but high in copper)
  • 3-4g of clove

  • 4 cups of brewed tea

If you do not avoid starches and PUFAs:
  • 45g pumpkin seeds

  • 20g pine nuts

  • 1 cup lima or winged beans

  • 1 cup of brown rice or quinua

Rice bran is really high, but we would have to know the effects of the bran anti-nutrients...
I also need to start eating more manganese rich foods. Where you see that clove is high in copper? Cronometer and nutrition data shows low copper.. I like buckwheat or millet, but they are high in copper. I will start with gluten free oats..
 
Last edited:

bruschi11

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
3,011
I just had a “maple water.” Manganese for days.